You mention Sm4sh 3DS as a basis for Sm4sh Wuu, but they were released the same day. It's the same game.
1.im fairly certain me going w/ my friends at target at nightime to get the 3ds version and going to gamestop for the wii u version during the day w/ another group of friends happened in different days (both launch days)
2.you're right about the same game part, so in a way you can sorta excuse it; however it still feels like a brawl 2.0...or 3.0; whereas brawl had its own feel from melee
As for the Mario argument, IMO, that's a problem with the Mario franchise as a whole, since many of them aren't very dissimilar. And honestly, same with Smash. You can't fault Wuu for that.
I can't ague the others because I don't know enough about their games/series to make an argument.
mario started to head that route during the late wii,but instead of rectifying that,wii u made it worse
Now, let's look at the Wii. Home to Ocarina of Time, Metroid Prime, Golden Eye 007, Mario Power Tennis, New Motion Control! Pikmin, New Super Mario Bros Wii, and others. The Wuu isn't exactly the only console ever to have remakes or rehashes.
.....what?
here's what i noticed,when people bring up good wii games,they can often mention over a dozen of original titles; w/ wii u lists,wind waker was almost always among the first five they bring up, not a whole lot stands out it seems
and obviously it isn't,though it's more of an issue w/ this generation than just the wii u
Or maybe you should talk about how horrible the 3DS library is, what with Ocarina of Time 3D, Star Fox 64 3D, Donkey Kong Country Returns 3D... honestly, the 3DS is worse than the Wii U in that case.
difference w/ the 3ds is there's a plethora of other more original games in it's library, not so much w/ the wii u [but yes,there are a noticeable amount of remakes on 3ds]
also i don't know if this is a good point or not,but handhelds seem to be a bit null when it comes to ports of older games; such as the gba and the mario advance series,link to the past,nightmare in dreamland,pokemon fire red,dk country trilogy,final fantasy 1 - 6,etc.