- Joined
- Dec 21, 2023
- Gender
- Male
Hi!
Which dungeons are better? To be honest I'm not sure...
Just wondering!
Which dungeons are better? To be honest I'm not sure...
Just wondering!
Tears of the Kingdom Which Dungeons are better?
- Thread starter WoodelChick
- Start date
- Joined
- Nov 23, 2023
I spent a lot of time in BOTW, I’ve doubled that in TOTK
If that means anything…
If that means anything…
Honestly, this is tough for me. The Divine Beasts are still really cool and the concept of fighting these huge structures in order to get inside them is still super awesome. The physics-based puzzles were fun, too, and so was changing the orientation of the entire structure. They really did good on them.
And then TotK's dungeons go back a bit in the traditional direction, feeling like once-lived-in parts of the world but still following the cool open-ended format of the predecessor. The environments and puzzles were really fun, and the dungeon approaches didn't leave me wanting. All of them were incredibly atmospheric and fighting side by side with the Sages all the way through was amazing. I think that's the detail that pushes them to the top for me. I love cooperative party gameplay, and the Sage Vows make me extremely happy. I was begging for that long before TotK and even BotW came out. So I gotta go with TotK on this one.
And then TotK's dungeons go back a bit in the traditional direction, feeling like once-lived-in parts of the world but still following the cool open-ended format of the predecessor. The environments and puzzles were really fun, and the dungeon approaches didn't leave me wanting. All of them were incredibly atmospheric and fighting side by side with the Sages all the way through was amazing. I think that's the detail that pushes them to the top for me. I love cooperative party gameplay, and the Sage Vows make me extremely happy. I was begging for that long before TotK and even BotW came out. So I gotta go with TotK on this one.
Totk dungeons are better but overall Botw is a better game
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2023
- Gender
- Male
Ok I changed my mind...
Its definately Tears of the Kingdom.
King Link
The Hero of the Kingdom
- Joined
- Jun 16, 2024
- Location
- The Great Sky Island
It has to be BOTW for me like I have spent 505 hours in BOTW and half that in Totk.
Also I just find BOTW dungeons more challenging and fun.
Also I just find BOTW dungeons more challenging and fun.
Yeah @King Link is right
Mikey the Moblin
if I had a nickel for every time I ran out of spac
Define dungeon
- Joined
- Nov 23, 2023
Fire Temple
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2021
- Gender
- man
My instinct is Breath of the Wild has better dungeons., but let's see.
Lowest Number Ranking:
TotK: 2+3+6+10+11+12 = 44
BotW wins!
Highest Number Rating:
Vah Ruta (5) is better than the Water Temple (1), by 4 points.
The Final Trial (7) is better than the Spirit Temple (2), by 5 points.
Hyrule Castle (BotW) (10) is better than Hyrule Castle/Gloom's Approach (TotK) (2), by 8 points.
The Wind Temple (8) is better than Vah Medoh (3), by 5 points.
The Fire Temple (6) is better than Vah Rudania (3), by 3 points.
The Lightning Temple (9) is better than Vah Naboris (7), by 2 points.
BotW: 3+3+5+7+7+10 = 35
TotK: 1+2+2+6+8+9 = 28
BotW wins!
Breath of the Wild has better dungeons!
This is because BotW's worst dungeons (Vah Medoh, Vah Rudania, and Vah Ruta) are not even close to TotK's worst dungeons (Hyrule Castle, Spirit Temple, and Water Temple). The Divine Beasts can be short and the aesthetics can be identical, but at least they do not match the aesthetics of the Sky and Depths, or just consist of a series of ridiculously easy combat encounters in different rooms. And Breath of the Wild's Hyrule Castle is genuienly a brilliant piece of design work.
Lowest Number Ranking:
- Hyrule Castle (BotW)
- Lightning Temple (TotK)
- Wind Temple (TotK)
- The Final Trial (BotW)
- Vah Naboris (BotW)
- Fire Temple (TotK)
- Vah Ruta (BotW)
- Vah Medoh (BotW)
- Vah Rudania (BotW)
- Hyrule Castle/Gloom's Approach (TotK)
- Spirit Temple (TotK)
- Water Temple (TotK)
TotK: 2+3+6+10+11+12 = 44
BotW wins!
Highest Number Rating:
Vah Ruta (5) is better than the Water Temple (1), by 4 points.
The Final Trial (7) is better than the Spirit Temple (2), by 5 points.
Hyrule Castle (BotW) (10) is better than Hyrule Castle/Gloom's Approach (TotK) (2), by 8 points.
The Wind Temple (8) is better than Vah Medoh (3), by 5 points.
The Fire Temple (6) is better than Vah Rudania (3), by 3 points.
The Lightning Temple (9) is better than Vah Naboris (7), by 2 points.
BotW: 3+3+5+7+7+10 = 35
TotK: 1+2+2+6+8+9 = 28
BotW wins!
Breath of the Wild has better dungeons!
This is because BotW's worst dungeons (Vah Medoh, Vah Rudania, and Vah Ruta) are not even close to TotK's worst dungeons (Hyrule Castle, Spirit Temple, and Water Temple). The Divine Beasts can be short and the aesthetics can be identical, but at least they do not match the aesthetics of the Sky and Depths, or just consist of a series of ridiculously easy combat encounters in different rooms. And Breath of the Wild's Hyrule Castle is genuienly a brilliant piece of design work.