Game Thread Trivia Mafia II - Day 1

[OGSniper]

be convinced if you talking about the heal thingy whatever its called u gave me

 

[JamieIsBored]

OG, thoughts on Rag's case on me?

 

[OGSniper]

Umm, I find it a bit weak, but anything goes as of right now.

 

[JamieIsBored]

Vote: DarthCreeper

Vibes are off, quiet and I don't like the call-out of what OG sent him.

 

[OGSniper]

The whole reason I had decided to talk about what I sent him was the fact that HHH got resusitated. I had sent him a heal-shot, so I thought it was DC who administered the heal thingie to HHH. It is kinda not lookin' like that is the case.

 

[JamieIsBored]

It seemed like it happened immediately. Like someone logged on for phase change and already had the action prepared. If Darth did revive HHH, I'd expect there to be more consideration.

 

[DarthCreeper10]

Vote: DarthCreeper

Vibes are off, quiet and I don't like the call-out of what OG sent him.

lol last time i talked too much
i wasn't sure what to do i haven't used the heal shot yet cause i just got it like 8 hours ago

 

[HangryHangryHippo]

The whole reason I had decided to talk about what I sent him was the fact that HHH got resusitated. I had sent him a heal-shot, so I thought it was DC who administered the heal thingie to HHH. It is kinda not lookin' like that is the case.

This seems odd. Like I would expect you to know the form and function of what you're sending. So you should know if it's capable, and if it is then you should just assume it was the package and not give away that you are creating such things.

 

[OGSniper]

Huh? I am sorry but I dont understand what you are trying to get at. It is a one shot heal. What do you mean by creating things? Not to throw Darth under the bus, but he was the first to say that it was a heal thing. I am just confused on what you are saying.

 

[HangryHangryHippo]

I'm saying it's of no benefit to out that information, either that Darth has access to an ability that can raise the dead or that your role generated such things with correct questions. So it's very odd for you to bring it up at all. It's also very odd for you to try to throw DC under the bus without throwing DC under the bus by saying he said what it was first when you made a concerted effort to breach the subject with him.

 

[OGSniper]

I find it quite useful that I got the affirmative from DC. My role generated what now? I have my reasons to bring it up. I was not trying to throw DC under the bus. I already stated that. I didnt quite understand what you were saying earlier so I was putting some stuff out there that I thought was going to help clear the air. The whole reason I had brought up sending something was the fact that you rose from the dead. I thought DC did the deed of bring you back, but it turns out that it wasnt DC's doing. Not a problem. Think what you will, but I dont know why you say that there is no benefit of this info being public. I want to see what crystal ball you used to determine that.

 

[DarthCreeper10]

tbh i thought just saying it would be helpful mb

 

[OGSniper]

You are absolutely fine DC. Either way of saying it and not saying it is cool.

 

[Mellow Ezlo]

~Vote Count 2.1~

JamieIsBored - Ragnarokio (1)
DarthCreeper10 - JamieIsBored (1)
Not Voting - OGSniper, DarthCreeper10, HangryHangryHippo, lain, Rocinante

4 votes are majority. Day two ends November 11, 11:59PM MST (28 hours).

 

[Ragnarokio]

Lmao, this is such a weak case when HHH easily had the best role claimed for being town proven.

I hadn't really considered this and it does make it weaker. HHH's role wasn't confirmed and a hint-giving role is possible as scum, especially if its intended that they use the role on themselves (and HHH decided to use it on a town player instead in order to win town pants). Considering they died, i don't think this is the case, but its possible that a scum team not involving HHH could feel that HHH's role would not be too threatening to them if confirmed. I know you and I tend to have pretty divergent feelings on clearing players using this sort of information though, and so i can believe you might prioritize killing HHH for this reason if you were scum.

the cases are something like "jamie is scum and killed HHH to reduce heat on them", "jamie is town and scum killed HHH to increase heat on jamie", "jamie is scum and killed HHH for other reasons (such as the one you posed), "jamie is town and scum killed HHH for other reasons (such as the one you posed), and "scum didn't kill HHH"

The fifth case has negligible odds and can probably be discarded. As the odds of the first and third cases become higher, the odds of you being scum become higher. As the odds of the second and fourth cases become higher,, the odds of you being town become higher.




You've convinced me that the ods of the third and fourth cases are higher, which lowers the odds of the first and second cases, but that doesn't necessarily lower your odds of being scum, because you've effectively introduced two new cases which could result in your chance of being scum going either up or down, and considering you're someone who would likely kill HHH in a scum position it probably doesn't make it go down.

@OGSniper
@DarthCreeper10
@lain
@Rocinante

If you were scum, who would you have prioritized killing last night?