Here's a little bit of a reads list I guess. More just of where I'm at at the moment to get my thoughts straight because there are so many people to keep up with in this game.
Players:
- @Tristan
- @Kerest
- @Maniacal
This is the group of people who I'm liking for one reason or another and don't want to lynch right now.
Funnier - I understand part of what he's been going on about and trust him. His breakdown about what to do about his role felt really genuine to me and not manipulative.
Moe - I said before that he was all over the place, which wasn't meant to be bad thing. He was prodding other places while an easy wagon built on Ex.
SMS - I believe his claim. I'm dumb and wasn't thinking when Moe pointed out that he claimed he wasn't mafia then claimed he was town. Because I he could figure out from role actions last night. Plus I feel like SMS has been putting more effort into scum hunting than when he's usually scum.
Rubik - It's hard for me to read Rubik typically. I haven't seen anything unusual from him so far. And I kinda like that when I asked for a case on funnier he didn't push one when he could have. I even said I was probably gonna sheep someone and he didn't try to take advantage of that when I was looking for cases other than Ex.
Sunfan - While he hasn't actually done much so far in terms of scum hunting, for some reason him saying that anyone who claimed they knew anything n1 was bullshitting and then realizing he could've guessed day 1 felt like genuine frustration of not knowing what was going on. It may not exactly mean he's town right now but I at least think he doesn't know he's mafia.
ExLight- Sure he's been confusing people and had some out there ideas, but he's seems to have genuine motivations behind his actions. And also just seems like an easy mislynch for scum to push especially because not everyone knows their alignment/roles so I feel their more susceptible to following leads.
Null
Deku - Hasn't said much.
Zinn - Same as Deku. Did confirm Deku's claim, but I don't think that means they're town.
LG - just subbed in and Doc didn't say much before either.
Hero - He's always hard for me to read. I didn't like that he easily jumped on the Ex wagon because of lack of other suspects. And then easily backed off of it as well. But I feel that kind of behavior is NAI for him sometimes. And others seem to be liking him so I won't go with scum reading for now.
Max - He's here because he hasn't done much for me to read into, but again others who have more experience with him think that this is his town play. I don't have enough to townread him myself, but I'll trust others enough to keep him out of the scum pile.
Capsfan - Has been chiming in every so often with some decent looking stuff. Which also kind of reminds me of his play in the hydra (or at least of his other head, not sure who posted what). But I believe I've heard he's a really good player, so I'll need more to get a better grasp on his read.
People I'm left with
Tristan - There's something that feels off to me about Tristan. I'll have to re read some stuff to see if it still holds up or not.
Kerest - I feel she has also caused some confusion/chaos. I do think the thinking Ex is scummy but backing off when others did isn't great. And also seemed to set up a "Moe looks like he's trying to defend a scumbud" to put him in a scum pile after the Ex lynch started going nowhere. It was especially weird because Moe wasn't the only one saying to look elsewhere at the time but was the only one she said was scum protecting scum.
Maniacal - I'm not entirely sure I think he is scum. I'm just really not sure. His intial case on Ex looked decent, but that could be easy for scum to fake. And his arguing that someone not guessing alignment day 1 was bad when he also didn't want to isn't great either.
I'm leaning towards Kerest right now. Will have to reread some of Tristan's stuff to make sure though. This is all my reads without iso-ing people, so I might have some stuff wrong/misremembered.