Game Thread Batmafia - Game Thread

[Mikey the Moblin]

I mean this is a decent line of thought but I can tell you you're wrong here. There was only one scum on Ex's wagon.

I refuse to listen to this unless you have a mechanical claim to back it up
if you have a way to confirm it, that would be insane because you are clearing 4 people as town

 

[Johnny Sooshi]

Also, of course funnier flipped red.

No wonder scum didn't try anything on me last night.

 

[Morbid Minish]

I refuse to listen to this unless you have a mechanical claim to back it up
if you have a way to confirm it, that would be insane because you are clearing 4 people as town

I actually do.
I would rather not claim at the moment, but I do have actual mechanical reason for it.

Also only clearing 3 people.

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

Claim it
3 clears is worth it
That's like better than a cop can do sometimes

 

[Morbid Minish]

Claim it
3 clears is worth it
That's like better than a cop can do sometimes

I will if people are cool with it. Because it will make my PoE make more sense and give everyone something to work off of.

I also have to clarify something first.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Vote Count:

Rag (4) - Minish, Kilza, Echo
Kilza (1) - Moe

Not Voting - Namira, Rubik, Storm, Johnny, Rag, Doc, KoD

Night 2 ends at 11am PST on Saturday, December 21st. With 11 alive, 6 is majority.

 

[~Kilza~]

Claim it
3 clears is worth it
That's like better than a cop can do sometimes

Okay. I'll take the role claim for today, then. I'm a 1x Town Cop and Mason w/ Minish. Used my cop shot on Johnny last night since he was the opposing wagon and I wasn't too sure on his alignment and he came back as innocent. That's why Minish knew Funnier was the only scum on Ex's wagon.

 

[Storm]

Okay. I'll take the role claim for today, then. I'm a 1x Town Cop and Mason w/ Minish. Used my cop shot on Johnny last night since he was the opposing wagon and I wasn't too sure on his alignment and he came back as innocent. That's why Minish knew Funnier was the only scum on Ex's wagon.

Thats seems thin

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

works for me
unvote
vote: kingofdominaria
post I quoted shows implicit knowledge that minish is town
never mentions minish before then to read them as town
it's wolf posturing after post-buddy flip imo

 

[Morbid Minish]

Thats seems thin

Do you think we're scum trying to clear a townie with fakeclaims? Because that would be a little crazy.

Either way if one of us flips it will prove it anyways so still 2 townies cleared at that point.

 

[Johnny Sooshi]

works for me
unvote
vote: kingofdominaria
post I quoted shows implicit knowledge that minish is town
never mentions minish before then to read them as town
it's wolf posturing after post-buddy flip imo

I'm trying to follow this, but I'm not sure what post you mean.

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

I'm trying to follow this, but I'm not sure what post you mean.

the one that I quoted on the previous page

 

[Morbid Minish]

I'm trying to follow this, but I'm not sure what post you mean.

Funnier interacted a lot with Ex and you (Minish). He barely interacted with me other than to tell you he wanted me lynched, and to show surprise at my town reading him. This leads me to believe he hasn't interacted with his mafia team in thread.

 

[Rubik]

Okay. I'll take the role claim for today, then. I'm a 1x Town Cop and Mason w/ Minish. Used my cop shot on Johnny last night since he was the opposing wagon and I wasn't too sure on his alignment and he came back as innocent. That's why Minish knew Funnier was the only scum on Ex's wagon.

I really wish you'd targeted me.

I made a show of it for a reason.

At least we can break up this game up into one where either you're both town (more likely) or both scum (unlikely, but not worth eliminating). In theory, there should be no world where Johnny is anything but town or godfather.

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

c u l t i s t s