• Welcome to ZD Forums! You must create an account and log in to see and participate in the Shoutbox chat on this main index page.

Game Thread Anime Mafia 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 3, 2019
a bunch of people have subbed out so if I forget someone, sorry
order doesn't really matter in any of the tiers

feel good about
sunfan- kawaii desu-ne
rubik- his role is super-duper lucky if he's scum because its v unlikely for him to get any mileage out of it unless funnier is exactly 3p like that. just town
minish- yeah... despite the funnier shenanigans, there's probably not a world where she's a wolf taking this hard of a stance on funnier. Picking up where she left off wrt Hero's slot is legit a gross read but it means she's probably town because she only kind of scumread Hero before, but now has really stepped on the gas wrt that slot today, and it means she probably replaced into the same alignment.
silverfish- the read has /slightly/ fallen off today given a few small things but the way silverfish reacted to pressure yesterday, to the point of admitting to making up reads, is not really a line I see scum take very often.

I could entertain the notion that they are town
funnygurl- minish put it well when she said that she thinks FG is town, but wouldn't cry if she died. Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if she was 3p again, it just kinda feels that way rn.
SMS- kinda surprised to see him so low since I usually think he's bleeding town by now; def haven't hated anything he's said but it feels like he's had limited presence and I can't really fall in love with that. OH **** he had a great reaction to funnier claiming 3p he's probably not a wolf with him ok that's a read I guess. a funnier wolf flip would look p good for this boy.
Lar- honestly the fact that I'm townreading him probably means he's a wolf. I don't really know how he would feel if he replaced into scumchat and saw funnier with a fakeclaim like that, but I do know that lar is a very comfortable buser. The main reason I don't want to hurl him into the sun is because it felt like he was giving his actual opinions that he had when he was reading the thread before he replaced in (wrt his read on me and his read on funnier). yea, he could be a wolf doing that, but I don't /think/ he is and am ready to roll my eyes when I have to work out his alignment further than this on d5.
Irvine- def the weakest of the reads. honestly its just pure meta to the one game I've played with him. The way he adapted from forgetting that he said that one of the funnier pushers was scum, to scumreading me after I pointed that out didn't feel like it was a scum trying to impression-manage, if that makes any sense at all

no strong opinion
deku- if you put a gun to my head and told me "Tell me something Deku has said this game or I shoot" then I'd say "tell my boyfriend I love him and want him to find another"
laurentus- I know there was something he did that I didn't like but I don't remember what it was so he's off the hook for now.
lg- butts. I'm not good at reading her, as I've come to find out.
ragnar- idk man this is probably the read I should shore up the most.

kinda wolfy
ex- ya. Was expecting a bang when they ISO'd me, but then it was a whimper. Then they're happy with their vote on catchup, presenting the way that they're catching up in a "look at the way I'm doing this, guys" manner. Feels like scum who is trying to like, get behind a reaction they know they're going to have to have.
all might- meh. Hero felt barely, barely town but I'd honestly sheep Minish here quite happily. not my own opinion tho.

funnier-tier
funner- guess we'll find out what he is at the end of today, eh? I almost hope that he's 3p that was lying just so that the 3p in the past 2 games get absolutely bodied in the early-game.

yes I know there's probably 4 wolves alive but I only have 3 wolf leans rn leave me alone
 

MixMasterLar

Beach Bum Extraordinaire
Joined
Aug 30, 2019
Location
The Emerald Coast
Exo most of what you're asking/talking about gets answered but I will answer this

It really isn't. This is the kiddo's 6th game and as I said I'm taking responsibility from it since it was my idea.
Is there any reason why expanding our options should be seen as gross? Info can always come from it.


What makes it gross is the way he goes about it
You may be wanting to prod at what you see as potential scum, but Silver just slapping a vote without question just feels bad. Considering they have the precedent of not being around for long periods of time and the ever ready excuse they're new that's just like a vote to show you're doing something without actually doing anything.

That's not opening options. If I just randomly voted Deku or Minish right now that doesn't open up more options. If I made a case, had reasoning and took a hard stance with a vote then it's a different story; but that didn't happen.

Also, I thought new was like under 3 games. This is his 6th? I don't see how one could fault me for calling him to action when 5 previous games should give you a good idea on what the goal is.

Anyway gonna ISO Rubik but in all honesty since we only have one claim it's straight down to just trusting he has the info and knows it's legit. What's more is that the flip won't likely help us determine that if funnier really is 3P, and that's not super optimal.

I'm not sure why SunFan thinks that the chances the flip are scum is higher now, I think it likely that Funnier claimed mostly the truth, but wanted to lie to avoid more backlash about if he knew for sure who his next target was. That said, the fact I have to take someone else's word without even so much as a claim sits wrong with me, but apparently claim caps are how ZD be so aight
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2019
this is why instas are good
we get rid of this stupid extension and you guys see that funnier is mafia, as the prophecy foretold, and that I'm a town dumbass
emphasis on dumb
 

ExLight

why
Staff member
Moderator
Was expecting a bang when they ISO'd me, but then it was a whimper.
ikr
I was disappointed too
40270
I was expecting some better stuff other than "Lynch funnier" in a hundred of posts

That's not opening options. If I just randomly voted Deku or Minish right now that doesn't open up more options. If I made a case, had reasoning and took a hard stance with a vote then it's a different story; but that didn't happen.
Pressure wagons are pressure wagons, they don't need to have the most elaborate logic behind them, do they? That's why they're used on D1.

Also, I thought new was like under 3 games. This is his 6th? I don't see how one could fault me for calling him to action when 5 previous games should give you a good idea on what the goal is.
5th or 6th, yea.
And you can know the goal by reading a wikipedia post, putting it in practice is a completely different story.
Do you really expect someone with that few experience to be aware of all these shenanigans?
Hell, this is like my 13th game and I'm still somewhat lost in quite a bunch of stuff.

is that the flip won't likely help us determine that if funnier really is 3P
It will, the color points out the alignment.
If it turns out to not be Red or Green then he's indept.
 

Ragnarokio

AVATAR NOT BY JIMMU
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Gender
If you don't identify as the default options of Male/Female, you may enter your gender here.
i'd be very surprised if funnier claimed 3p day 1 as scum.
 

Ragnarokio

AVATAR NOT BY JIMMU
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Gender
If you don't identify as the default options of Male/Female, you may enter your gender here.
as mafia specifically, that is
 

MixMasterLar

Beach Bum Extraordinaire
Joined
Aug 30, 2019
Location
The Emerald Coast
Oh yeah some reads that's what I've been craving

Sun Fan you're ability to forever fear me as the perfect wolf amuses me. You are absolutely right there that if I replaced as wolf I would ****ing chunk funnier straight at the lynchin' tree, but that's not happening so womp womp
I've done what Exo just did with his catch up before as town, and I swear DaBackPack does a variation of it every game. The thing is, this isn't that busy of a game (No, it isn't. No, we've had 4 replacements and 2 others basically quit this game is not crowded or gong that fast) so I don't get why he wouldn't just finish reading the thread and consult the quotes he tagged along the way.

I don't get the SMS reading but he's do for an ISO anyway so I'll get back to that I guess


I feel like there are at least 2 wolves in the inactive slots and if this turns into another "Sort by Postcount D2, win game" scenario I will cry like a 3 year old who say his parents get **** in the face
 

Rubik

King of Lorule Lounge
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Location
California
Gender
Horsehead
I'm pretty sure I know your role at this point, would you rather having me to keep quiet about it?
Honestly it might be pretty obvious for most people. Should we ask you for a watcher or protection tonight?
Do you know his targets?
Theorizing about this isn't productive for anyone but scum.

Coordinating town PR moves is generally bad, especially when we don't have any dead scum yet.
 

MixMasterLar

Beach Bum Extraordinaire
Joined
Aug 30, 2019
Location
The Emerald Coast
It will, the color points out the alignment.
If it turns out to not be Red or Green then he's indept.
I meant as in, If Funnier flips 3P then that's probably going to happen anyway regardless of if Rubik is pulling his knowledge outta the trash or not.
Not sure what the end game is if he is lying, though.
....And all I'll say with regards to Silverfish's vote is that a pressure vote that is clearly a pressure vote doesn't pressure anyone. Anyhow, regardless of if it was a good idea at the time or not, I stand by that I want to see him do more. We have plenty of time and I obviously don't expect him to solve the game in a day. Shoot, even if he is wrong on everything, it'll let me see how he thinks about it and maybe I'll be able to read him better for it.

as mafia specifically, that is

I don't doubt he is 3P
I just doubt it's a good idea to keep a 3P around
I think SunFan wants that to happen because he be like that though, but some weird next level gambling was happening if funnier is actually scum.
 

ExLight

why
Staff member
Moderator
Coordinating town PR moves is generally bad, especially when we don't have any dead scum yet.
Is it? It seems a lot worse not being able to discuss tbh.
We don't know whether or not they already know our roles, so it's a natural WIFOM for town.
We might as well WIFOM them.

I'd be fine with asking for a Watcher to watch you so we guarantee you don't get Roleblocked or NK by scum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom