Search results for query: *

I trusted both of you. @Spider-Bok @Jamie :( I'm sorry town. I was awful this game. Scum didn't even have to defend themselves, I was doing a good enough job of that at the end. But seriously like I said, if Jamie and Bok were scum they kinda deserved to win at that point because they had me...

Hm, looks like you quoted my post by accident. I think you meant to quote your own there. :)

Yeah, but it's still anti-town, which I would say fits with the trend. Oh yeah, forgot about that. Haha. I still just don't think he's lying about being a commuter. A lot of my town reading Jamie comes from him being so defensive when people were scum reading him. I feel like he usually gets...

Meh, might as well. Vote: Midorikawa

Favorite water starter is a cloud and fire starter is a match. :cool:

I doesn't mean mafia can't, but there's been a trend of town/scum having similar roles. Yeah, he could be bullet proof, but why not just claim that instead? But the thing is, if there's only one scum left it can't be Jamie (if he's commuter, which I believe), so you go after the other person you...

His role claim seems to check out with me targeting him that night, and I don't think commuter would be a likely scum role. Especially when SK was commuter as well. I know that's using his role, but in this case we don't know if there's one or two scum left, so in a scenario where it's either...

Midori was aggressive towards Jamie as her old role, when she was town. But now she could be scum, and trying to put a little bit of distance between her and Jamie if they are scumbuds. Not that I think they are, but I can see where Bok's coming from with that.

If you feel like Midori/Jamie is a possible scum team, then why not vote for Midori when others already said they'd vote for her? You and Lone seem to have the same outlook about her Jamie vote, but like I said before, I could see both Libk and Jamie being town and if Midori is scum, she would...

I agree that it's OP at this point in the game, but if that slot had been active before we could've possibly figured it out before now and determined from their actions whether it seemed scummy or not. But I am starting to think Midori might be the best lynch today if we decide to lynch someone.

Oh yeah, just saw that. That's weird, since Dylan said 48 hours at the beginning of the day phase which would be in 3 and a half hours. I don't know which it is then.

I don't think it's a fake claim, but I was thinking it could be a scum role. I feel like all the claims right now could be true, it's just a matter of whether they're town aligned or scum aligned.

I think we should have 3 and a half hours left.

If we decide to lynch someone today, Bok and Jamie are kinda out of the question for me. I don't see me voting for either one unless it came down to the three of us left and the game was still going. So that leaves Lone and Midori. I was originally thinking Lone would be the best candidate due...

Gonna go ahead and unvote for now, since like Jamie said, we should re-evaluate the no lynch idea. Unvote

I was actually thinking about the Lone situation after I voted for no lynch. It certainly puts us in a tricky spot no matter what. If Lone is a mafia double voter, and there's still two scum left, then we're pretty screwed going into the next day anyways. With Finn being modkilled, and another...

Since Finn is being modkilled I agree that a no lynch would probably be our best option right now, especially since we don't know how many mafia are left. He was looking like the one to be lynched anyways, so the outcome is still the same. Vote: No Lynch

But if Jamie is town, then I can still see why should would vote him over Libk, because at least Jamie is here and has been posting. Libk was never active until then, so she wouldn't have to worry about him as much as Jamie if she's scum.

The only vote she's had since she subbed back in was the one on Jamie, so I don't see how you can read into her voting patterns that much.

I feel a little iffy about Lone's claim. Not that I don't believe it, but that role could be town or scum and I don't like the idea of scum having doublevotes this close to the end.

Man, I really just don't know where to go from here now. Music is confirmed. I don't really see any situation where Bok is scum. His actions have been too townie. Jamie's claim seems to check out and he's been looking town to me lately. Only way he's scum is if there's still two scum left...

Vote: Libk I don't like the fact that as soon as it's mentioned that everyone who doesn't post in this day phase will be modkilled, Libk conveniently shows up. I feel like he doesn't want to lose scum the game that way, so he's trying to seem somewhat active now so we'll go with someone else...

Kinda surprised that Lone was the nk target. Also, still confused by all that sensor stuff. Because Emiya sorta made it seem like there actually was a sensor that was maybe just relaying stuff through him, but that doesn't make sense either unless they're one of the inactives. Libk popping...

All these townies claiming to be things they actually aren't. How am I not supposed to be suspicious of that when things don't add up? Sorry Emiya, but we were still kinda right there even though we didn't lynch scum. :/

Gonna go to bed soon, so this will be my last post before eod. But given what I stated before, I feel like lynching Emiya might be in our best interest. He's the only active person left that I feel has been kinda scummy, and I don't want to let him slide by on just his claims anymore when even...

Yeah, I was going to mention something about Kuro being the backup in my other post, but I forgot. It seems weird to me that he was just the backup Jailkeeper, for you supposedly, but you have all these other abilities as well that he wasn't the back-up for. Not sure if that's a common thing in...

The thing is though, is that it's super easy for you to fake a sensor shot if you're scum. You would know if there were at least one scum on the wagon, and could say that there was only one so that when we lynched that person, we'd look elsewhere. Not to mention, I still think your claim is just...

Just now saw this post for some reason. Anyways, sorry about that, but I felt more comfortable targeting you than a random inactive. Due to what I said before, and the fact that Space had you as a town read for some reason and I thought maybe since they put Pendio as one of their scumreads they...

Yeah, I targeted Jamie but my shot was unsuccessful.

My thinking with choosing Jamie was he's the last unaccounted for semi-active person, and mafia is still making kills so that would fit. Plus we don't really have anything to go on with the inactives, so it would be a huge guess and I only have one shot. At least if Jamie is mafia, and there's...

I'll target whoever, as long as there is a consensus. While I don't see anything particularly scummy from Jamie, I don't see him as a bad target just because we know there's a least one somewhat active scum left. And he seems to fit that. But I can also go for someone that's inactive since...

It's hard to get a read on Jamie, when I don't have a lot of posts to go on (I know you were busy though, so I'm not faulting you for that, just that I can't read what's not there), but these recent few posts would normally give me a town lean on him. Either that or he's actually scum and just...

What in the world? Funnier and rainami claiming masons this whole time caused a lot of confusion, which could have been avoided. I can get why they wouldn't want to claim lovers as that would give mafia two kills, but they had other roles as well and didn't have to counter claim masons. Also...

Well if you believe Emiya, than at least one of those people have to be scum. I'll lay out my reasoning again for Space, and reply to your post about them along the way. These two posts are contradictory and go against your defense of Space. First Space said that you seemed suspicious for...

I didn't actually vote for him. But I kept rainami on there because it's not 100% totally confirmed, though I did put her last because of that though.

I think this is a good idea. It would be helpful if everyone posted their list of the rest of the people on Pendio's wagon. We have a vig, so if there's a consensus on the most suspicious person, the vig could just use a shot on them. I'm going to leave Emiya off of my list, because we have to...

I mean, you didn't really even give up until people starting suspecting you. That's just how these games go. You're going to be found suspicious. You just have to work through it.

I saw that. Still doesn't change the fact that so many people giving up on the game is the reason we're in the place we are now.

If there's scum among the inactives then you wouldn't find out how many scum were left with that plan anyways. We'll find out if there's scum there if at some point kills stop happening and the game is still going. I wasn't going to vote for someone I didn't feel was scummy just to lynch them...

Despite scum reading Pendio, Space never really seemed to push him much. It's not exactly uncommon for scum to put one of their buds in their scum list to gain town cred later on. I think he may have meant that you're new in the sense that you subbed in for someone, so you're a whole new role...

Well if that isn't extremely vague. You're not even lynched yet, so saying "I'd have looked her way if I was still going" doesn't even make sense. You are still in the game. The way you talk yourself out of getting lynched is by proving yourself and making cases for why other people seem scummier.

Not having evidence to back up calling Lone and Midori out looks pretty bad tbh. And they're not confirmed town so easily. Midori has been under suspicion, but claimed 2x role cop. She said she used it on Space and found out their role, which would be pretty hard to fake. And Lone just subbed...

Any certain reason why you have Lone highlighted like he's a confirmed townie?

Saying that we look suspicious for pointing out why you look suspicious just makes your case even worse. But I wasn't even going after you in the first place. I think it's been pretty clear that I think Space is scum. I was just pointing out that some of the things you do certainly can look...

People are going to be suspicious of you. That's the point of the game, since you can never really discount anyone unless they are proven town. Voting yourself doesn't really do anything, since scum has done that before too. Also, Bok was the first to vote Feenie and you seemed to mainly just...

I've already said that I didn't find the case on him very strong, and that I was still pretty weary of you. So I was going to vote for someone I did feel better about voting for, instead of someone I didn't just because you claimed to have a plan. Plus if everyone was on Pendio's vote, that...

Alright, I'm just going to say I don't have any issues with people using OC at all. I feel like others are misconstruing our problems with the OC. I do think it can be useful in some aspects, but not when people are gathering information outside the thread and then using that information to make...

I'm still giving him the benefit of the doubt for now, since he seems to have a plan he wants to try out which if it works will give us a lot more information to work with. And I will admit that he's drawing a lot of attention to himself with a risky plan if he is scum, so that makes me a little...

Between the people who have either claimed in thread or to other people and the inactive people, I'm left with only about 4 choices. None of which I feel have done really done anything scummy. Not really liking this wagon on Pendio right now, since he hasn't said a whole lot and what he has said...

I know you were responding to Bok, but I just wanted to say we are trying to scumhunt in thread. But OC kinda makes that hard, as it seems like everyone else is doing their own thing and we're left in the dark. How are we supposed to push lynches or anything on our own, when others are voting...