Alright. I've noticed Xinnamin for a while now, and thought that I'd finally bring up my argument in a more appealing way.
I have to say, though... not a lot of really awesome evidence can be brought up as a lot of her posts add absolutely nothing... but aren't avoid the modkill, so I don't know what to think. Here's an example:
Well, Day one moved so fast I couldn't get in in time, and now that I've read through everything that happened, I can't really say I've got any major suspicions since most of Day 1 was directed at Elfen. The few other odd posts that surfaced, like Zenox or Ats, a lot of it may just be newbie mistakes and/or overeagerness, which was clearly the case with Elfen. I'll wait for more evidence before making any more deductions.
Ignoring the suspicion of me, this is basically a recap of what's going on. Sort of fine for a first post, I guess. But note how it happens the next 3 times that she posts, as well. She simply recaps what's going on. Oddly, though, they're not spaced out time-wise. They're just sort of annoying.
I believe that he is a Townie due to the fact that he can't be the Mafia because no Serial Killer in their own right state of mind would attempt to kill themselves hoping that the Doctor would save them, thus clearing their own name of being the Serial Killer.
Wait, what? Why can't he be mafia? I'm not following that logic...or was that just a typo?
This post is clearly just annoying. He of course meant to say Serial Killer instead of Mafia. Most of her posts at this point (5 posts in at this point) are just annoying or add nothing whatsoever, yet, again, aren't avoiding the modkill. ONly thing I can think of is that she's posting to try make people trip over themselves with their tiny mistakes so they have to rephrase things and screw up. I'm gonig to call this an "annoying scum" for obvious reasons.
The possibility of him being a "clone" of my behavior in the last game is the biggest thing that preventing me from outright voting for him right now. Granted he IS a lot more volatile, but that could still be rookie aggressiveness due to inexperience and not knowing any other way to play. The fact that he's kept it up so long and so intensively is concerning though, so I still suspect him.
Just so you know, she's talking about MK9 here. MK9 is clearly not an inexperienced player, and if he is, he's clearly got a good strategy, due to what we've seen the past day/night barely. I think his strategy was flawless, only thing that brought him down was our own vigilante's over suspectful-ness.
Right now, I'll FOS both of them and go back to try and make better sense of everything that has happened.
This is going to add on to my main point against Xinnamin, to make it look like she's actively playing, she does FOS people, but never follows through with her word of getting more information on them and finally voting. She only actually voted once, and the turnout of the lynch was townie.
Sorry for the inactivity, been busy all week, will be busy next week too fyi. Anyways, reading through everything, I think that Dracomajora should be lynched. There's not much evidence to point out that hasn't already been said, PA and Panda covered all that pretty well. Draco's been really confusing his posts, and that kind of confusion can distract from the investigations at best and hides scum behavior at worst. Either way, it's not good.
Vote: Dracomajora
This seems like a "go with the flow" sort of action, just jumping on the bandwagon without really thinking about it. She's trying to do what the crowd does to not look really obviously different. Not to mention that it's clear that Dracomajora is only 11 years old, and his posts look more like rookie mistakes than anything we have ever seen. Yet this is the only post that she does not mention could be a rookie mistake. Perhaps she was trying to cover up her scum friend MK9 by mentioning rookie mistake earlier(though it clearly wasn't any rookie mistake), and then doesn't bother to try to defend Dracomajora with mention of OBVIOUS rookie mistakes because she knows that he's town. This was her only vote, and it ended up flipping townie.
Well, so far we haven't had too good a track record, a lot of townies dead and that needs to stop. Frankly, I get the feeling that with as many participants as we have it's really easy for scum to stay alive by avoiding discussion and thus avoiding attention, thus all the townies that are actively trying to root out the scum get targeted for lynches. That's not to say all of our active players are townies, but I think we may need to start looking at the more inactive people who only drop by once in a while to avoid modkills for inactivity. I know that some of those less active players may have just been too distracted by real life to contribute large investigation analysis, goodness knows I was for the last weeks, but it's just a thought that I had.
This is another one of those "stick with the crowd" type moments. NOt adding very much, but basically rephrasing what people had already been saying. "Go after the inactives." She uses this to avoid suspicion. All she did was suggest an obvious tactic because everybody else was. Right now it just looks like she's trying to avoid any suspicion. Of course we all want to avoid suspicion, but she seems to be trying
very hard to avoid suspicion even though nobody has suspected her.
My thoughts are this: Bay was a townie, and MK9 had to have known that. At the same time, she was under a lot of heat from a lot of people last day period, meaning she was relatively safe to go after. Now, doing a ton of scum analysis on someone just to have them turn townie doesn't really help your standing amongst other townies, so I'm thinking that there's a high likelihood that one of MK9's other suspects is scum, so if they get lynched later MK9 could further fool everyone (he was getting some heat recently too). Maybe you're right that the SK just missed the deadline, but if the SK was actually roleblocked, then that raises the possibility that one of MK9's suspects was the SK.
Regardless, I just thought it wouldn't hurt to keep an eye on people like Epwna and RP (still not sure if there's any significance behind him analyzing you and switching that scum label, might have just been a save-face sort of measure to make him "less perfect" and more believable in his act) I, like many people, have said that inactives should be looked at, and MK9's scum reveal just gives me more reason to do so.
Another totally obvious post, no one didn't already know this. She suggested something that was suggested multiple times before, so it didn't add anything at all to the discussion. Trying to blend into the crowd sort of post.
Yes that is very convincing. [/sarcasm]
Sorry, but are you trying to get killed? Because with the evidence and suspicion against you and that kind of paper-thin defense, you're well on your way.
Another just blending in sort of post. She doesn't really add anything. Not saying much at all.
Seriously, though, almost all her posts fit this description. They are either jumping on the bandwagon or stating the obvious to attempt to blend in with the rest of the crowd. It seems like she's trying
very hard to do this as well. She just tries to avoid getting lynched by doing what everybody else is doing. She never really helps much. While this is a good strategy, once somebody starts to look through your posts, the pattern is noticed immediately. I noticed this pattern about 3 posts in, and I'm really getting tired of looking through these pretty bland posts. I'd say that Xinnamin's probably the SK, due to the SK just trying to blend in than really trying to turn everyone against each other, but it's definitely a good mafia strategy as well. I'd encourage you all to vote.
And so I end with:
Vote: Xinnamin
