personally, i agree with you. (IMO) the time cycle sucked, the dungeons sucked, and the story wasn't very deep.the game could have denounced these things without being an Oot clone. it could have done this by focusing on the masks, new story, and new location. Oot established the 3D zelda style, so being a lot like it wouldn't have been a bad thing. when this game came out, people were expecting an Oot-like adventure. the reason people were didn't like it as much is because it changed too much. you can still have an Oot style adventure without being a clone, just look at TP.
P.S. the save system sucked too.
Oh I beg to differ,
As majora'smagic posted before, the dungeons did not suck. They were probably the most complex dungeons of any 3D Zelda game! With the Great Bay Temple and the Stone Tower you had 2 dungeons in one! THAT must have taken more planning than OOT's Water Temple. They were also unique in the sense they were designed for a different form of Link, and in Stone Tower you had to use all three forms of Link. You said the dungeons suck, you haven't told us why you think they suck.
Yes, I agree the time sequence was annoying, but you can get around that by slowing time by playing the song of time backwards. But the time sequence is also a unique feature that's never been introduced in any Zelda game before, and a good challenge for veteran players.
The storyline, how do you think it sucked? The world is about to be crushed by a giant moon! Each region of the land had it's own deep storyline as well!
The Swamp was plagued with poisonous waters
The Mountain was frozen in an eternal winter
The Ocean was becoming murky and terrorized by pirates
The Canyon fell to petty battles of greed and the dead still couldn't rest
Kafei was turned into a child and his wedding mask was stolen
There were multiple story lines each proposing their own problems and each got more complex through out the game.
And a game based off OOT like TP would probably not have been welcomed... How you you feel if SS was similar to TP which is similar to OOT? We JUST had a game with these certain elements, we don't want a "new" game exactly the same, that would just be upsetting. (Honestly, TP was a bit of a letdown in the sense the game was very easy, kept with the Forest, Fire, Water sequence and didn't even have elemental arrows D= )
What you're saying could be legit but you didn't provide us with any reasons supporting what you're saying and why.
P.S. Yes, the saving was very inconvenient.