Your list is also like mine but upside down
It's pretty similar to funnier's, if he flips scum for some obscure reason would that change how you see these players?
Game Thread Anime Mafia 2
- Thread starter Pen
- Start date
- Status
It's pretty similar to funnier's, if he flips scum for some obscure reason would that change how you see these players?
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2016
Your list is also like mine but upside down
It's pretty similar to funnier's, if he flips scum for some obscure reason would that change how you see these players?
If funnier flips scum I have to reevaluate the whole game. But usually me and funnier being on the same wavelength is a good thing.
I'll still feel the same about sunfan probably, and SMS. Definitely All Might.
May feel less good about an FG lynch then. Because I'm willing to trust funnier a bit that he can read her better and I think she gives us a ton of info. But if somehow funnier flips scum I wouldn't trust that read as much.
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2017
- Gender
- Male
The way the players are thinking it feels like I'm in a rut trying to choose between forums. Is it treacherous that my own forum mates are scummy in my eyes?
I get that you and funnier are close Minish, but in a mafia game that seems like a very foolish call, especially when you two are usually really calm and calculated.
I get that you and funnier are close Minish, but in a mafia game that seems like a very foolish call, especially when you two are usually really calm and calculated.
I just agree with you way too much oof
You're the only one that seems to be sharing some of my points of view here
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2016
It's not because we're 'close'. It's because we usually read eachother very well. And I'm not throwing out everything I know about funnier all of a sudden. This is just like the original Anime Mafia where only I believed him and I was right to do so.
Rubik
King of Lorule Lounge
I can understand kind of where they're coming from because funnier doesn't normally pull this kind of play.
It's possible that funnier is telling the truth about his role and his faction, but the fact that he obscured relevant information when I directly confronted him means I can't trust him to act in town's best interest.
It's possible that funnier is telling the truth about his role and his faction, but the fact that he obscured relevant information when I directly confronted him means I can't trust him to act in town's best interest.
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2017
- Gender
- Male
I'm aware, I saw the two of you post that "This is like a repeat of the first Anime Mafia!" So obviously he is thinking the same way as you. Do you really think the situation is following exactly like last time and you're the only one that understands him and that you're "right to do so" again? You don't think funnier thought about this before hand and is trying to pocket you knowing you'll come to his aid again?
Rubik
King of Lorule Lounge
He omitted information because he didn't know I'd be able to catch it, and that's not a valid excuse.
Even so, I don't think you should hide behind him if you're Town, especially when he's about to get lynched.
We'll get to D3 soon enough, that's usually midgame, and we're still focused on the same stuff from D1, which is baseless. Not only that, but you're asking us to trust someone who prolly had to kill around 2 Townies to win (if the killing 4 wincon is true the ratio should be around 2-1-1 to be somewhat impartial).
We'll get to D3 soon enough, that's usually midgame, and we're still focused on the same stuff from D1, which is baseless. Not only that, but you're asking us to trust someone who prolly had to kill around 2 Townies to win (if the killing 4 wincon is true the ratio should be around 2-1-1 to be somewhat impartial).
Is this entire dejavuish thing a soft, Minish? Or do you really feel like this?
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2017
- Gender
- Male
This. This is EXACTLY why I wanted us to wait until later for a role claim, as funnier's was sketchy anyway, as expected. Your claim would have been a much better idea instead of being the vague way I see it now. I guess it's the fact that I don't play Mafia as often as the rest of you that I can't pick up on the apparently obvious hints, but focusing on funnier has been an enormous waste of time so far. I honestly just want to lynch him to end this endless back and forth and move on with the game. He's either scum or 3rd Party, no loss for town asides for Minish apparently.
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2016
The repeat thing was more me dying n1 and subbing back in then anything. Though him being 3rd party aligns again.
But no, I don't think he'd do that. I'm sure he knows I would defend him, but he also knows that I'm only one person out of a whole game. One where he knows how sunfan feels about 3rd parties and that most others don't care if they're lynched or not. So it'd be crazy to rely only on me defending him.
i know i liked the post sorry but i agree
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2016
What do you mean hiding behind him? Of course I'm going to argue against a lynch I don't like. And like I said, if he needs town dead then they could always be nk'd anyways. If he tells us if he finds one of his targets (which he doesn't know if they're town or scum) then we know who he needs killed and he can't try to sway a lynch.
It's not a soft. Dunno how it would be. Lol.
I really feel like this. I'd much rather lynch someone I feel is scum than 3rd party.
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2017
- Gender
- Male
Okay. Setting funnier aside for the moment. Why are your Top 3 Lynches where they are? What about them makes them scum in your eyes? Help us see what you see and maybe we'll look at them tonight instead of funnier.
@All Might Stop lurking, it's creeping me out man.
- Status