Game Thread DW's Very Creatively Titled Mafia

[Ragnarokio]

I trust Ex more than I do Killjoy, the circumstances for Ex to be scum are super niche and I don’t think that’s what this game is. The gimmick is obviously the neighbours other than that it’s quite a basic game. I seriously doubt triple bluff roles, and I’m more lenient on Miller claims than you seem to be.

what makes them super niche?

 

[JamieIsBored]

Loud visitor mafia. That’s not a common scum role and made for the specific purpose of a fake claim, which I don’t think is what this game is aiming for. I think its worth letting Ex try again and if it magically fails the second time we lynch him.

 

[Ragnarokio]

i'm as lenient on miller claims as makes sense statistically. a miller claim lowers the EV on a red check from ~100% to ~66% in this case, with the numbers going up or down some depending on your other considerations. If the circumstances were different, this could be enough to make it worth lynching elsewhere.

 

[Ragnarokio]

Loud visitor mafia. That’s not a common scum role and made for the specific purpose of a fake claim, which I don’t think is what this game is aiming for. I think its worth letting Ex try again and if it magically fails the second time we lynch him.

is it normal in your meta to treat loud visitors as confirmed town?

 

[Ragnarokio]

where i come from mods typically vary setups somewhat to try and keep that kind of metagaming from being effective.

 

[JamieIsBored]

is it normal in your meta to treat loud visitors as confirmed town?

It’s normal to treat miller claims as nearly confirmed, but we claim D1 if miller. Loud visitor would pretty much cement it.

 

[Ragnarokio]

treating a miller claim made after a red check as nearly confirmed doesn't make sense, and so the loud visitor portion is all that matters here. I don't like the idea of treating loud visitor as an innocent child variant but if the bulbagarden players say thats how the role typically works then i can trust that

 

[Ragnarokio]

@Mint Elv
@ExLight

Are loud visitors typically treated as confirmed town?

 

[DawningWinds]

Votal 2.4
KillJoy262 (5) - ExLight, HangryHangryHippo, Minish, JamieIsBored, Mint Elv
ExLight (4) - Ragnarokio, lain, Storm, OGSniper
lain (1) - DarthCreeper10
Not voting (1) - KillJoy

 

[JamieIsBored]

These wagons are so much yummier than Day 1’s.
@DarthCreeper10 You and @Killjoy262 are the only ones not on either of the two main wagons. Killjoy will likely self-pres onto Ex so Darth, who do you think is more suspicious?

 

[DawningWinds]

Oh right:
DarthCreeper10 has requested to sub out. The substitute is currently pending and it's unlikely Darth will be able to participate before the sub is found.

 

[JamieIsBored]

Oh, nevermind then.

 

[OGSniper]

Rather unfortuante is DC departure from the Forums...

Lets have a moment of silence.....

 

[Ragnarokio]

thats too bad they were fun to play with

 

[Mint Elv]

treating a miller claim made after a red check as nearly confirmed doesn't make sense, and so the loud visitor portion is all that matters here. I don't like the idea of treating loud visitor as an innocent child variant but if the bulbagarden players say thats how the role typically works then i can trust that

If this was BMg I would lynch immediately. But I know millers outing here is not common.

@Mint Elv
@ExLight

Are loud visitors typically treated as confirmed town?

Depends if the game is intended as chaotic or bastard.