The Xbox One controller is not a step back, it's definitely an improvement.
The bumpers are more... slanted? They form to your fingers better. Triggers have their own feedback. It just falls into your hands smoother. It's easy to use. Along with the lights in the front of it, the kinect is supposedly able to track your movements with the controller, analyze it with the game play to figure out which player is which in game.
However, I don't like certain features of the xbox one and I'm not entirely sure if you can blame the controller, but it's sort of related. For example, when typing something in a search bar (with your alphabet at the top of the screen), you can no longer hit a bumper to skip ~7 letters or so. So that's minimal but quite irritating.
I find the controller easier to use and more comfortable. I do like the 360 controller and haven't really used it since getting the One, so maybe I'm just used to the new one.
The bumpers are more... slanted? They form to your fingers better. Triggers have their own feedback. It just falls into your hands smoother. It's easy to use. Along with the lights in the front of it, the kinect is supposedly able to track your movements with the controller, analyze it with the game play to figure out which player is which in game.
However, I don't like certain features of the xbox one and I'm not entirely sure if you can blame the controller, but it's sort of related. For example, when typing something in a search bar (with your alphabet at the top of the screen), you can no longer hit a bumper to skip ~7 letters or so. So that's minimal but quite irritating.
I find the controller easier to use and more comfortable. I do like the 360 controller and haven't really used it since getting the One, so maybe I'm just used to the new one.