From what I've seen from most of the Townies, they may have questionable motives for their actions, but they all operate on "gut feelings" or hunches, and I'm starting to understand that now.
However, ALit and Minish have been the hardest people to read for me because they provide pretty good analysis and reads, yet I can't place them as scum or Town. Their posts have been based on logic and reasoning for the most part instead of hunches, as have mine, but... I get the feeling their motives are purely deceptive. Throughout this game, I've felt like I've been tricked and messed with multiple times because when the Townies slip up, I tend to immediatetly lash at their throats instead of considering why they would do that, and I feel like that's been taken advantage of. I'm gonna change gears a bit this time around.
Vote: A Link in Time
Unless I'm being ravagely mind****** right now, I think he's the godfather. I've looked at all the lynches so far, and he has never counterwagoned a single one of them. In fact, on the second day lynch, he URGED me to STAY on the Doc wagon. He was also the hammer vote Day 3, which I now find suspicious since he didn't even wait for HylianEVAN to respond
before taking karu's post into consideration. This is out of character for ALiT
. I've always thought he was an analytical guy who always takes time to look at everything and hearing everyone out before placing a vote, but this makes me believe he knew Deku was Town and didn't want D3 to go on for any longer than it needed to.
Tl;dr- Unless either karu, Ayano, or Ver-go is screwing massively with me, I think ALiT is scum.