Ok here's the dealio. I forgot to add a 100% choice (nice going zellinkda) so I decided just either choose not to vote, or you can vote for the last game you finished. in your example I see, it would be minish capuhm...is there a "I've played all of them" option?
...I don't know what to do now. That last one I did play that ended my "haven't played" streak was minish cap.