You know the Kokiri sword also has a red gem.
There's hardly any detail to really make a comparison beyond black slender and red gem
But you understand how this is different, right? By this logic we can’t make any comparisons because if we get vague enough we can make strawmen arguments like “Oh, you’re comparing their designs? Well guess what, the Four Sword and the Master Sword both have
blades. I guess they’re the same now too?” Obviously black, red gem and slender isn’t conclusive evidence that confirms everything I said, which is why i said it’s something that
could be argued.
In my prior post i edited it to show the ending of the Demise battle where he's defeated, you literally see the sword disintergrate or whatever it's called.
Right, and I understand the possibility he was simply eradicated from existence, but I don’t think there’s enough evidence one way or another to say this is exactly what happened. We know Ghirahim is capable of teleporting/making items appear and disappear at will (which he has multiple animations for). We also know that, while the sword spirits exist inside the two blades, when the sword spirit is dormant/defeated/etc, they just become regular blades, like the Master Sword in most entries for example (not to say the Master Sword is the same as the Kokiri Sword or something; it’s still the Blade of Evil’s Bane, just no sword spirit is active). There’s really no reason for Ghirahim to randomly disintegrate, especially since Demise wasn’t even dead; I’d argue if Link just left him like he did without absorbing him into the Master Sword, he’d most likely still survive.
The issues i have really is the Demon sword doesn't have the aura nor.........."menace" oft he trident, it's a utilitarian blade it's there for cutting not for fanciness, the trident is more Ornate a rulers weapon as it were and so it's built like that, not to mention FSA Trident could be thrown about and the sword "can't" then again with Ghirahim he could probs throw a sword. I do get where yer coming from though. you could easily see these as being built by the same beings.
I can understand this point but I think this one comes down to personal interpretation. The Trident of FSA doesn't really look ornate at all to me; the only thing I think that’s ornate about it is the red gemstone. In terms of the aura, I can understand that point, and I think it’s probably because Ghirahim isn’t an actual Demon King or a King of Darkness. We see the aura of the Anti/Dark/etc etc Master Sword in SS when Demise uses it, and the aura of the Trident when Ganon uses it.
The fact that in the child line we don't actually see any hint of the trident until FSA kinda lends credence to the trident coming from the demon tribe.
Oh I definitely think even if they aren’t related both Ghirahim and the Trident are Demon Tribe artifacts. The Trident is specifically what turns Ganon into a demon and allows him to become the King of Darkness (of course, not the Demon King however; the Trident isn’t Triforce level.)