I'd like to think I'd get Courage, but I probably wouldn't.
Normal stuff people squeal at doesn't really bother me.. spiders, snakes, blood etc. (gore really doesn't bother me for some reason... mummified bodies on the other hand...) Heights also make my legs go weak, however, but with enough determination you can still manage things. But courage isn't about having no fears, it's about overcoming them when you need to.
Like what Shadsie said, I tend to be pretty stubborn and very determined when I set my mind to something, and I don't tend to let accidents or bad experiences faze me. The very first time I finally went Ice Skating (I could already do it because I roller-bladed a lot) my skate hit a hole in the ice, and I went flying, shredding the skin on my elbow and hip, scraping my hands raw, and bruising my cheek. Friends clinging to the sides like "Omg are you okay?! Omg I'd be sat at the side right now", but I went and cleaned myself up, and came straight back on and skated around again, no big deal. I didn't even think anything of it until they started fussing. I guess it comes from climbing trees and walls as a kid- if you fall then you get back up and try again. I guess that's become one of my philosophies, but I'm getting off topic.
I don't mind getting my hands dirty either, heh I remember once I was at a camp with school, and we had to do this teamwork thing building this path across the mud with slabs, and one of them sunk right into the mud, you could barely see it, and in the end it was me who dug my hands right under and pulled it out (even though there were several boys on our team). I also tend to stand up for others too, and if someone I know's in danger or pain, I'll do whatever I can to help them, not matter what will happen to me personally. I'm not afraid to voice my opinion- if something's not right then it needs pointing out and fixing, not carefully stepping around because someone's to afraid to point it out. Again, sometimes I should keep my mouth shut more, buuuut.
And, by my own logic, I've just proved why I'd almost certainly get Wisdom instead. I love to look deep into things, philosophy is a subject that really interests me. I love to learn about the world and how it works more than anything else. I find you feel so alive, so necessary when discoving something new, a facet of life you'd never before uncovered. I tend to waffle on to people about things that no one but me would ever find interesting, but that doesn't matter. I guess I'm still just a curious kid inside. I also find people tend to come to me when they're upset- they say I know just what to say to make them feel better, that I have words of wisdom for every situation xDDD
...actually, at first I was annoyed I'd get wisdom, but actually it fits me well.. better than I thought. It'd be cool to have it, actually. This is an awesome thread.