General Art Voting: GCC Week 5 - Music Signatures

[Baysiderulez]

Hello Folks... So We only had two entries this week. Not sure if its cuz you guys are busy or because you didn't like the theme. Remember you can always post in these threads with ideas for future themes as well as PM me with your ideas... there's a 98% chance they will be used.

Anyways lets get on with what you all came here for anyways...

This weeks Theme was MUSIC. Please select the sig you think is the best.

Mandym287

The Green

So yes...Vote for which one you think is the best. Both of our contestants this week did an amazing job. Please give them your critique as well so they can become even more thriving artists.

-------------------------
GCC Week 6

Theme: Anime

Medium: Signature

Due: Saturday, October 2, 2010 @ 11:59PST
(-8:00 GMT)
------------------------

Good Luck I look forward to seeing your entries!
​

 

[Kybyrian]

I think I'm probably going to go with mandy's. TheGreen's is very good and very simple, but it just isn't my style. Mandy's could have been less busy, because the render's are kind of concealed there and it looks kind of funky because of it, but it's still very good. I like the symbol right there in the middle. It's a good space taker, relates to the theme, and also looks nice.

TheGreen's note up at the top right is kind of concealed, but that's not a huge deal. The text is very nice and I love the lines and how he cut off the red-black gradient halfway through the image. The sudden change from upward to down on it almost seems to disrupt the flow of the signature, though. I don't know if this just my eyes or what, but instead of curving smoothly that line also seems to be a little more crooked. These flaws aren't really anything big, and it just not being my sort of thing is what's mostly drawing me towards mandy's.

 

[badmuffins]

Mandy's looks great. I like the colors she used. I think TheGreen's is a little to simple.

I vote Mandy.

 

[Magatha]

I like Mandy's, The Green's is nice too.

 

[Majora's Cat]

Mandy - it was bursting with life. TheGreen's was pretty good too, but not as stylish.

 

[(◕‿◕✿)]

TheGreen. Mandy's feels too cluttered, and I don't like the way the orange looks against the black background.

 

[TheGreen]

Thanks for the feedback guys.
I always find myself wishing that I didn't have homework and such so I could spend more time on these XD
I like making my own patterns and such and part of the reason why my sigs are sparse is because it generally takes more time that just using a brush,
BUT THAT'S NO EXCUSE!
I'll be better I promise

 

[kindlyone]

i personally liked mandys because of the zelda charecters

 

[Baysiderulez]

Thank you to everyone who voted!

This weeks winner is

Mandym287 Congrats!
​

Remember Next week's entries are due on Saturday, Get em in!