I was always a Nintendo girl (though I had Sega and Nintendo consoles), sure back in the 90s Sonic WAS cooler than Mario, but Mario's games were always much better (in my opinion).
As much as I love the eay 2D Sonic games, Mario still always had the upper hand in quality for me.
Mario also found grace and dignity in 3D (on his first go too!) Whereas Sonic didnt... (in my opinion).
Since Sonic's jump to 3D his life has been a bumpy one. In my opinion even his best 3D games are still clunky messes (though him being voiced by Chris Redfield tickles me).
Sega dont seem to be able to get Sonic wholly right...
This has made me wonder if anyone could do Sonic right. Sonic hasnt had his Prime or Galaxy or Ocarina game since his jump to 3D... but could a developer other than Sega give it to him if Sega let them?
So, who do you think could stand a good chance of giving Sonic his wholly good 3D game?
It can be anyone you like; Retro Studios, Platinum Games, whoever it is that made Horizon Zero Dawn.
Who do you think could actually make a good 3D Sonic game on the levels of Mario Galaxy, Metroid Prime and Ocarina of Time?
Or is Sonic damned?
As much as I love the eay 2D Sonic games, Mario still always had the upper hand in quality for me.
Mario also found grace and dignity in 3D (on his first go too!) Whereas Sonic didnt... (in my opinion).
Since Sonic's jump to 3D his life has been a bumpy one. In my opinion even his best 3D games are still clunky messes (though him being voiced by Chris Redfield tickles me).
Sega dont seem to be able to get Sonic wholly right...
This has made me wonder if anyone could do Sonic right. Sonic hasnt had his Prime or Galaxy or Ocarina game since his jump to 3D... but could a developer other than Sega give it to him if Sega let them?
So, who do you think could stand a good chance of giving Sonic his wholly good 3D game?
It can be anyone you like; Retro Studios, Platinum Games, whoever it is that made Horizon Zero Dawn.
Who do you think could actually make a good 3D Sonic game on the levels of Mario Galaxy, Metroid Prime and Ocarina of Time?
Or is Sonic damned?
Last edited: