I have finally finished binging all the Star Wars TV series I wanted to see now. I have watched The Clone Wars, The Bad Batch, Rebels, The Mandalorian, The Book of Boba Fett, and Visions. Took me two months to get through it all. Aside from rating them, I feel like ranking them compared to each other. This is probably the best thread to do that rather than making a blog or something about it.
Clone Wars (seasons 4-7) > Mandalorian > Bad Batch > Rebels (season 4 and finale of 2) > Book of Boba Fett > Clone Wars (seasons 1-3) > Rebels (seasons 1-3)
I'm not going to bother ranking Visions compared to them since its a collection of anthologies and that would require ranking all 9 of them individually. I will say that episodes 3, 4, 5, and 8 were peak. 3 was my personal fave just because it felt like Studio Trigger had an absolute blast making it, moreso compared to the rest.
The Clone Wars 8/10 - The beginning of the Clone Wars was a little hard to sit through, but the payoff was so worth it later. The final four episodes became one of my absolute favorite storylines in the franchise and seasons 4-7 basically redeem the prequels as a whole. Ahsoka Tano is a fantastic character and she made that series really shine for me. She's my favorite character in the franchise now. The slog of the first three seasons was well-rewarded.
The Bad Batch 6/10 - The Bad Batch was short but it had some interesting stuff. It follows characters introduced in the Clone Wars and covered the immediate aftermath of Order 66 and the founding of the Empire, which was pretty neat. I'd watch a second season if they make one.
Rebels 3/10 - Rebels was mostly painful to watch. It felt like they tried to replicate what made Clone Wars good without understanding why it was good. Ezra was unbearable as a protagonist at times. Season 4 being a consistent storyline with real stakes was the highlight, as was the season 2 finale. Ahsoka's involvement kept me going through it.
The Mandalorian 7/10 - The Mandalorian was pretty good. I'm glad I watched the rest before watching this since all of these series ended up being so interconnected. I wasn't too crazy about Mando as a protagonist at first, but he turned out better once el babito entered the scene. The second season was pretty great stuff. Was kinda cool to see how the galaxy is faring after the Empire fell.
The Book of Boba Fett 4/10 - The Book of Boba Fett was a slog. The first four episodes were painfully bad. Boba is not the same character he used to be and the excuse as to why was pretty lame. A ridiculous amount of the run time was set to unnecessary backstory exposition. We didn't need a 50 minute origin story for the pointy stick he used to beat up stormtroopers when he appeared in Mando. The last three episodes were good literally only because they brought the Mandalorian back in to carry the show's dying carcass to safety. They are the reason why it's still rated slightly above the first three seasons of Clone Wars and Rebels.
Very much looking forward to the Ahsoka series in the future, as well as seeing how Kenobi turns out.