I really liked the Hobbit. I'd give it 10/10.
Don't believe these rumors about the framerate being a problem, these people don't understand what that is and what the technology means. All the higher framerate is, it shows more frames, images, each second, 48 instead of the usual 24. All that does, all that can do, is make all the motions smoother and less jarring. That's it. Not this nonsense about making you sick or anything. It cannot do that. It's not technologically possible. Not with just the framerate. If you're getting that, it's something else, not the framerate. Don't spread this misinformation about high framerates being bad for nonsense reasons.
I didn't have a problem with CGI. Everything looked real to me, even in moments where it was clearly something a person couldn't do and had to be a CGI double, it still looked like them. I thought the CGI was excellent. IT has to stop being treated like this evil thing. If it's done right, which it was, it's great.
Anyway, I liked the things they changed from the book. For the sake of no spoilers, I'd just say, I liked every change. And that certain group at the end that doesn't talk.... c'mon, talking animals doesn't work well in live action movies. It's difficult to work with. Either all animals talk, or none of them. They don't get a special pass. That was a good change. I think the purists need to lighten up. I loved the book. And I think this is a very faithful adaptation that makes reasonable, sensible changes. Not many though.