Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
Rating: 5 out 10 (use to be 9 out of 10)
This use to be my favorite prequel, I even mastered using Anakin's damaged Praetor hilt lightsaber in duels, and sport his hair right now. Upon re-watching, the transition to the Galactic Empire and Anakin's fall is too abrupt, you go from first quarter of movie feeling like a follow up to Attack of the Clones, and then you have literally in some scenes such radical shifts, you have Palpatine worried Anakin will kill him saying, "If one is to understand the great mystery, one must embrace a larger view of the Force, not just the Dogmatic view of the Jedi," to "learn to use the dark side of the force and you will be able to save your wife from certain death." This is too abrupt a transition in minutes, that line about save your wife should have waited till the confrontation in his office when Anakin arrives, and the revelation Palpatine knows Anakin is married would help tip him over the edge. Palpatine suddenly going anti Jedi is too abrupt, when in the optics they rescued him from Grievous at the beginning, a better way to do it is Mace Windu who kept verging dark, suggesting, "The Jedi will have to take over Senate to bring about peaceful transition," and "He is too dangerous to be left alive." Use Mace and his strike team as what Palpatine needs to turn public opinion against the Jedi (which he does, but make it the watershed moment) and leave out he suddenly mistrusts them and puts Anakin on the Council.
Much of movie is like this, too abrupt of a shift, it need a Mini Series or at least two part movie to make it believable.
I had to say it, its my least favorite prequel now, despite the quota lines that get memed a lot.
Also I agree with Ebert and Roeper when it came out, too many duels. It is interesting my estimation of this film has radically changed and here at the Twentieth Anniversary this April.