Game Thread Raccoon City Mafia (Game Thread)

[CynicalSquid]

Vote Count

Spiritual Mask Salesman (1): Kirino
No Lynch (3): Rubik, Spiritual Mask Salesman, Mellow Ezlo

Nothing happened part 4

The Living (4):
1. @Rubik - Sherry Burkin the Innocent Child
2. @Spiritual Mask Salesman
3. @Mellow Ezlo
4. @Kirino

The Dead (9):

Johnny Sooshi - Eveline the Queen of the Mold (Lynched day 1)
funnier6 - Jill Valentine the STARS Investigator (Blown up night 1)
Echolight - Tofu the Survivor (Devoured day 2)
ExLight - Chris Redfield the STARS Vigilante (Exploded with a knife in his head night 2)
Morbid Minish - Nemesis the Umbrella Strongman (Shot in the head night 2)
Soneji - William Birkin the Umbrella Disabler (Killed Day 3)
Doc - Ada Wong the Mercenary (shot in the head night 3)
Moe the Moblin - Rebecca Chambers the STARS Medic (shot in the head night 3)
Poyzin - Claire Redfield the STARS Disabler (Killed day 4)


Night 6 begins

Please send me your night actions by Thursday March 5 at 4PM MST

 

[funnier6]

Nothing happened part 4

Can we get a summary of parts 1-3 I blinked

 

[CynicalSquid]

And once again, for the fifth time in a row....

Spoiler

nothing happened

The Living (4):
1. @Rubik - Sherry Burkin the Innocent Child
2. @Spiritual Mask Salesman
3. @Mellow Ezlo
4. @Kirino

The Dead (9):

Johnny Sooshi - Eveline the Queen of the Mold (Lynched day 1)
funnier6 - Jill Valentine the STARS Investigator (Blown up night 1)
Echolight - Tofu the Survivor (Devoured day 2)
ExLight - Chris Redfield the STARS Vigilante (Exploded with a knife in his head night 2)
Morbid Minish - Nemesis the Umbrella Strongman (Shot in the head night 2)
Soneji - William Birkin the Umbrella Disabler (Killed Day 3)
Doc - Ada Wong the Mercenary (shot in the head night 3)
Moe the Moblin - Rebecca Chambers the STARS Medic (shot in the head night 3)
Poyzin - Claire Redfield the STARS Disabler (Killed day 4)

Day 7 begins

With 4 alive it takes 3 to reach majority. Day phase ends Sunday March 8th at 4pm MST

Also I'm removing the voting for no lynch rule. Effectively making it LYLO.

 

[Rubik]

Also I'm removing the voting for no lynch rule. Effectively making it LYLO.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Can we just lynch Kirino? Like we've gone over before, Soneji roleblocked me, if we were scumbuds that'd be a waste of an action. After Day 6 we can deduce Tristan is a Town JOAT, so that just leaves Kirino.

 

[Kirino]

SMS didn’t target anyone.

Vote: SMS

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

SMS didn’t target anyone.

Vote: SMS

I also didn't target yesterday either but there was a shot.

Anyway, there is enough known evidence here that it should be obvious that I'm not scum.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Like, for one, Minish was gunning hard for Kirino, why didn't they just nightkill him? If he was a Town tracker, and he was tracking correctly, why didn't they do something about him?

 

[Rubik]

Killing sms is probably the best move. There's no confirmation of him doing anything.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Killing sms is probably the best move. There's no confirmation of him doing anything.

This is the least optimal move. Why would Soneji target me? If we entertain the notion of him trying to block you and it redirecting to me, blocking you is just as wasteful of a night action. And I mean my god Rubik, read into my meta if you have to.

 

[Kirino]

The only possible scum is SMS, whose claim has been the weakest from the beginning: unlike Tristan and I, who softed our claims prior, his was only made in response to significant pressure. It’s also been easy to defend, as backup is uncommon enough that it’s unlikely to be counterclaimed, and anyone can make up fake cop claims. His claim has also never been verified, unlike everyone else’s here.

By contrast, I softed a day before I claimed and before I was under any real suspicion, and in order to lynch scum. If I were scum, then you have to believe that I planned out all of the following in advance: I not only chose to bus both of my scumbuds in a row, but actually lead lynches on them, even when it wasn’t clear they were going to be lynched. All this on the supposition that I could survive the whole game as the only mafia, all based on some fake tracker claim where I would keep having to make up results. This would be an incredibly risky strategy, to say the least.

And then there’s my tracking results themselves, every one of which has been confirmed. Sure, maybe I could have figured out Tristan targeted Doc. Maybe I could have figured out that Tristan targeted Rubik the other night. Maybe I could have even gotten lucky and guessed that SMS took no action last night. But what are the odds that I got lucky enough to guess all three, when even one wrong “guess” would have gotten me lynched? It defies belief.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

The only possible scum is SMS, whose claim has been the weakest from the beginning: unlike Tristan and I, who softed our claims prior, his was only made in response to significant pressure. It’s also been easy to defend, as backup is uncommon enough that it’s unlikely to be counterclaimed, and anyone can make up fake cop claims. His claim has also never been verified, unlike everyone else’s here.

By contrast, I softed a day before I claimed and before I was under any real suspicion, and in order to lynch scum. If I were scum, then you have to believe that I planned out all of the following in advance: I not only chose to bus both of my scumbuds in a row, but actually lead lynches on them, even when it wasn’t clear they were going to be lynched. All this on the supposition that I could survive the whole game as the only mafia, all based on some fake tracker claim where I would keep having to make up results. This would be an incredibly risky strategy, to say the least.

And then there’s my tracking results themselves, every one of which has been confirmed. Sure, maybe I could have figured out Tristan targeted Doc. Maybe I could have figured out that Tristan targeted Rubik the other night. Maybe I could have even gotten lucky and guessed that SMS took no action last night. But what are the odds that I got lucky enough to guess all three, when even one wrong “guess” would have gotten me lynched? It defies belief.

Well for one, Minish was nightkilled. Two, Soneji was dead weight in the Day phases anyway, so bussing him would be strategically beneficial to you, and clearly it is because you're tossing it now in the endgame, lol. You very well could be a bulletproof godfather with a tracking ability, too.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Who has the better roleclaim aside, there is enough known facts that contradict the scenario of me being scum and I can't stress this enough.

 

[Rubik]

Unfortunately, I was banking on there being more chances to no lynch after this so we could force sms to target someone, which would ensure that we could get a result where he targets someone and we could observe whether or not that target died. Unfortunately we don't have that, but this is the best result we have.

Kirino went hard after the scum team using his results. He's proven it's likely he has the ability he claims to have.

Tristan is unlikely to be scum if kirino is town.

This leaves you, sms, who has a claim that cannot be proven.

 

[CynicalSquid]

Unfortunately, I was banking on there being more chances to no lynch after this

I’m just gonna be honest if I had to write nothing happened one more time I would have mod killed myself so I decided to force your hand