Post Your Zelda Scores

[Shadsie]

LoZ- Banana
AoL- Shoe
ALTTP -Fruitcake
OoT- The Number Pi
MM - The Dessert, Pie
OoA- Unicorn
OoS- Santa Claus
WW- Atlantic City
MC- Button
TP- 99 Red Balloons
SS- Morgan Freeman


Okay, so I like all the Zelda games I've played and have a hard time rating them, so I thought I'd go surreal. (I was watching something making fun of mind screws last night). If you want a real rating, I guess... 8.8 for all?

 

[JuicieJ]

So I've started using a different scaling method. I've switched to a system of grade letters that cover a range of numbers, with the exception of the highest score. To make things easier to understand, it starts with is A++ (10), moves down to A+ (9.5-9.9), and keeps working its way down until it gets to F- (1-2.9). You can do the math to figure out the other scores. I'll keep my OP how it is due to the description prior to the scores, but I'm going to post them here according to how this new system of mine works.

The Legend of Zelda: A (Superb)
Zelda II: B (Very Good)
A Link to the Past: A++ (Masterpiece)
Link's Awakening: A+ (Amazing)
Ocarina of Time: A++ (Masterpiece)
Majora's Mask: A++ (Masterpiece)
The Wind Waker: B- (Good)
The Minish Cap: A+ (Amazing)
Twilight Princess: A- (Excellent)
Phantom Hourglass: A- (Excellent)
Spirit Tracks: A (Superb)
Skyward Sword: A++ (Masterpiece)

 

[DarkestLink]

A lot of these seem inaccurate and based on people's preferences more than anything. I realize preferences will play a role, but most of these look more like Tier Lists than scores based on the games overall quality and number of flaws.

Legend of Zelda: 10/10

Adventure of Link: 2/10

A Link to the Past: 9/10

Link's Awakening: 8/10

Ocarina of Time: 10/10

Majora's Mask: 9/10

Oracle of Seasons 7/10

Oracle of Ages: 9/10

Wind Waker: 7/10

Four Swords: 4/10 (See what I did there?)

Four Swords Adventures: 6/10

Minish Cap: 9/10

Twilight Princess: 9.5/10
GC:10/10
Wii:9/10

Phantom Hourglass: 7/10

Spirit Tracks: 9/10

Skyward Sword: 8/10

 

[Bokbok567]

Legend of Zelda - 6/10
Adventure of Link - 4/10
A Link to the Past - 8/10
Link's Awakening - 6/10
Ocarina of Time - 10/10
Majora's Mask - 10/10
Oracle of Ages/Seasons - 4/10
Wind Waker - 7.5/10
Minish Cap - 7/10
Four Swords - 6/10
Four Swords Adventures - 6/10
Twilight Princess - 9/10
Phantom Hourglass - 8.5/10
Spirit Tracks - 7.5/10
Skyward Sword - 10/10

 

[Not Take Mirror]

Ocarina of Time: 9.5/10
A Link to the Past 9.5/10
Twilight Princess 9/10
Skyward Sword 8.5/10
Majora's Mask 8.5/10
Wind Waker 8/10
Spirit Tracks 8/10
Legend of Zelda 7.5/10
Adventure of Link 7/10

I don't believe in giving out a perfect 10 because everything always has room for improvement even if it is a great game.

 

[JuicieJ]

I don't believe in giving out a perfect 10 because everything always has room for improvement even if it is a great game.

A perfect score doesn't mean the game is perfect. It just means it's as good as could logically be expected. It's breathtaking in nearly every way and could only use minor improvements.

 

[Kirino]

Legend of Zelda - 7/10
Adventure of Link - 6/10
A Link to the Past - 9.4/10
Link's Awakening - 7/10
Ocarina of Time - 9/10
Majora's Mask - 9.2/10
Wind Waker - 9.5/10
Minish Cap -9.5/10
Four Swords Adventures - 8.5/10
Twilight Princess - 9.6/10
Phantom Hourglass - 8.8/10
Spirit Tracks - 9/10
Skyward Sword - 10/10

 

[nsanesk8er16]

Legend of Zelda: 9/10
AoL: 6/10
Link to the Past: 10/10
Link's Awakening: 8.5/10
Ocarina of Time: 10/10
Majora's Mask: 10/10
Wind Waker: 10/10
Minish cap: 8/10
Twilight Princess: 9/10
Phantom Hourglass: 3/10
Spirit tracks: 8/10
Skyward Sword: 6.5/10

 

[ZeldaFan11235]

i haven't played a whole lot of games because I've been a fan for only about a year, but this is what I got,

TP 10/10 I love this game and i'm playing it for the 3rd time now. I loved the storyline and loved the graphics.
OoT 9.5/10 This was a really great game, but I thought the game was a little harder than I would like because of the water temple. I really loved the storyline, and the length of the game
MM 8/10 I haven't finnished it yet, but I'm very close. The only thing I really didn't like about this game is that you only have 3 days. I like to take my time.
LA 7/10 I'm about halfway, but this game isn't really one of my favorites. Mainley because there basically no storyline.
SS 10/10 I'm on the last dungeonof the game, but I absolutly love his game. I love the graphics and the great storyline. Its not too easy, but not too hard. Overall it's a really great game that I syggest very highly.
ST 8/10 I just got this game about a week ago and I'm on the 3rd dungeon, but it's pretty good so far. The storyline ism't my favorite, but its not bad. I'm not a big fan of this type of graphics.

 

[Tearbender]

A lot of these seem inaccurate and based on people's preferences more than anything. I realize preferences will play a role, but most of these look more like Tier Lists than scores based on the games overall quality and number of flaws.

Legend of Zelda: 10/10

Adventure of Link: 2/10

A Link to the Past: 9/10

Link's Awakening: 8/10

Ocarina of Time: 10/10

Majora's Mask: 9/10

Oracle of Seasons 7/10

Oracle of Ages: 9/10

Wind Waker: 7/10

Four Swords: 4/10 (See what I did there?)

Four Swords Adventures: 6/10

Minish Cap: 9/10

Twilight Princess: 9.5/10
GC:10/10
Wii:9/10

Phantom Hourglass: 7/10

Spirit Tracks: 9/10

Skyward Sword: 8/10

well this is called your personal Zelda scores, so this is what you would give the games. Like I gave Oot a 7.5

 

[Justac00lguy]

How Would You Rate Out of a Score of 100 the Zelda Games You Have Played?

I dont think I have seen a thread like this yet sooo...

I havent played all of the Zelda games but here's my scores:

Legend of Zelda 89
A link to the past 95
Ocarina of Time 97
Majoras Mask 98
Wind Waker 95
Minish Cap 91
Twilight Princess 98
Phantom Hourglass 91
Spirit Tracks 90
Skyward Sword 97

 

[Curmudgeon]

I'll just categorize them.

Favorite
LttP

Others I liked a lot
MM
OoT
OoS

Enjoyed
TP
SS
OoA
LA
LoZ
TMC

Tolerated
FSA
PH

Chore for me to finish
TWW
ST
FS

Ugly Runt that I love anyway
AoL

 

[Chameleon]

ALttP 90
OoT 97
MM 100
TWW 89
OoA/OoS 99
MC 91
TP 100
PH 91
ST 88
SS 95

 

[SavageWizzrobe]

LoZ 85
AoL 70
ALttP 86
OoT 98
MM 96
OoS 85
OoA 88
WW 93
FS 80
FSA 75
MC 90
TP 88
SS 94

 

[DarkestLink]

If I were to score them with little regard to my preferences...

LoZ: 85
AoL: 40
aLttP: 95
LA: 80
OoT: 100
MM:95
OoS: 70
OoA:85
Wind Waker: 70
FS: 50
FSA: 60
MC: 90
TP:99
PH: 80
ST: 90
SS: 80