Why does SK having commuter make it so that mafia can't? They're two separate alignments. There's also the possibility that he could be bulletproof and maybe another role on top of it. If there's one scum left and Jamies the commuter then I agree, he can't be scum but we don't know how many scum are left or if he's the comutter.His role claim seems to check out with me targeting him that night, and I don't think commuter would be a likely scum role. Especially when SK was commuter as well. I know that's using his role, but in this case we don't know if there's one or two scum left, so in a scenario where it's either Jamie/Midori, than Midori would be the better option in case there is only one scum left. Since Jamie couldn't have put in the night kill the night he commuted. Plus, I get a townie vibe from a lot of his recent posts. I feel like Jamie has certain tells as town and I've been seeing them. But he is a really good player, so I could definitely be wrong there.
Why though, even if she pushed jamie it was unlikely he would get lynched since her vote caused a tie and there were people on jamies wagon who said they'd be fine with a libk lynch also but no one on the libk wagon who said they'd be fine with a jamie lynch (if I'm wrong correct me but that's what I remember).Yes, both would've achieved the same thing if they were both town, but people were going back and forth between Libk and Jamie at that point and if I were scum I definitely would've been trying to push the Jamie angle then.