Pirates Mafia 2: Dead Man's Chest/At World's End

[pkfroce]

Theres a bus driver role...?

 

[Justac00lguy]

I think it's a good bet this is Thar's supposed role (jailkeeper). It would explain the roleblocks of Mellow and Alit.

 

[Pen]

Day 5 Vote Tally:
kokirion – 5 (Mido, Sadia, justac00lguy, Mellow Ezlo, musicfan)
Thareous – 1 (kokirion)
Mido – 1 (Thareous)

Vote Count:
thegreenrobby - 1
Heroine of Time - 1
Mido - 2
Dracomajora - 0
Rachel - 2
kokirion - 2
AvatarFlygon - 0

Remaining players have reached the post requirement of 3.

With 16 players alive it takes 9 for a majority lynch. Otherwise the day ends on Monday, February the 24th at 22:00 CET.

 

[thegreenrobby]

A Bus Driver is a role that 'swaps' people.
Say, a mafioso attempts to kill me. Also, a detective investigates you.
If a Bus Drive were to pick both of us tonight, I would be investigated, and you'd die.

This seems somewhat suspicious to me, especially coupled with the fact that he along with Green obstructed the successful implementation of the Scanner role plan yesterday. I do think this needs some more explanation.

I've said this more than once before. It was an accident and I wasn't paying attention. And even if I was doing it maliciously, it would be redundant to block the investigative role anyways.

 

[Ronin]

Thareous, are you sure that you're the doctor?

No, I'm not. Others have simply perceived my hints to mean that I am the Doctor.

Could Thar be the Jailkeeper?

This would explain why he has used it selevctily. One thing, Thar on what night did you protect me?

Not quite the Jailkeeper, but that could be a good suggestion for the dual role that supposedly keeps interfering with everything.

Night 2. You were the one leading the scumhunt that Day.

But you have a protective role right? Why not at least try and protect someone and get lucky?

Because some inconvenient role keeps throwing everything off.

 

[pkfroce]

Because some inconvenient role keeps throwing everything off.

However you didn't know that on Day 1.

 

[Ronin]

However you didn't know that on Day 1.

Exactly.

 

[pkfroce]

So why didn't you "protect" anyone on day 1?

 

[Ronin]

So why didn't you "protect" anyone on day 1?

As I've said before, nobody stuck out to me.

At this point a "you could have" argument would be irrelevant, and proceed down a route of baseless discussion which wouldn't contribute to in a worthwhile manner. By all means critique my decision if you want to, but I would only be repeating what I've already responded to with the same aforesaid questions.

 

[Justac00lguy]

To be honest all this talk about roles is getting slightly annoying now. We've been working off hypotheticals all game; it hasn't been very productive. Let's just focus on the game as I'm pretty sure Mafia are trying to manipulate discsuion to revolve around theories and such.

 

[thegreenrobby]

Well, all of these role claims are starting to become a bit of a headache.
Do you think we can go through and see if we could find any claims that may support other claims?

 

[Sadia]

I suggest looking into people who have kind of slipped under the radar, such as.... HoT, AvatarFlygon, pkfroce, Robby

 

[thegreenrobby]

I suggest looking into people who have kind of slipped under the radar, such as.... HoT, AvatarFlygon, pkfroce, Robby

Don't forget to include yourself.
Hooray! I'm post 1123!

 

[Mellow Ezlo]

Don't forget to include yourself.
Hooray! I'm post 1123!

Dude, Sadia's been scumhunting. In fact, we currently have a bandwagon on somebody mostly due to her theory. lol

And 1234 is better

 

[Ronin]

I don't care anymore...

Unvote

Vote: Kokiron

Please be scum, for the Town's sake.