ChargewithSword
Zelda Dungeon's Critic
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2009
- Location
- I don't want to say.
0. Ok, I'll try to reply using numbers like this
1. No problems with what?
2. LOL. Go to the Library in TMC. All books are written in TWW Hylian, meaning it is the dominant writing system used during that game period. One of the books even says "Triumph Forks"...
As for the alphabet existing in OoT, it was definitely not the dominant writing system, even though it could have existed for that long. TWW implies that they changed the writing system because of the flood.
3. You agree with what?
4. You are wrong. Miyamoto never denied the split timeline. Back in 2002 he even said that TWW followed the adult ending of OoT. And that was way before Aonuma confirmed it in 2006.
5. The same reason for FSA to come in the AT.
6.1. Doesn't matter. It is still surrounded by water, and it is not like that in either OoT or LttP. Also, there are only a few human settlements in FSA Hyrule, implying it is not a continent (like the two continents in AoL), but an island.
6.2. TP states that fragments are only left when someone who is not the true leader of the twili tries to destroy the mirror. Considering Midna was the true leader of the twili, she destroyed it completely.
7. You mean the Four Sword, right? The Four Sword is not the Master Sword! The only time the MS is used to seal Ganon in the SR is in OoT.
Miyamoto never ever confirmed that, I don't know where that is coming from.
8. Explain what you mean, because, in my timeline, there aren't two links coexisting at any point...
9.1.
That's in-game[/i]
9.2. It still makes sense without having to retcon it like you assume.
10. Who?
11. Said what?
12. Ganon was sealed in the Sacred Realm in the Imprisoning War, that doesn't happen in FSA. If I were you, I'd say that the IW happens after FSA, with the Sages (and the maidens from FSA are not sages either) sealing the 4S in the SR...
13. So you are saying that 2 mirrors that work about the same way are actually different mirrors? I see no reason to why that would be...
14. Proof for what?
15. Not true, the MS has been depiced differently in LttP and OoT, yet it was supposed to be the same. Art shouldn't be taken as evidence at all. But when we gather games that have similar artforms together, it forms a very good timeline:
http://img18.imageshack.us/img18/8594/coisahy0.jpg
(the image is too big )
16. Exactly. That's what I call 'deflooding'. It reverses the process of the flood. The flood (caused by the goddesses) made land "become" water, while deflooding (caused by trees) made water "become" land. The means they used to do that is debatable, but it is a fact that they have such power.
If the trees can swallow up water or pull the soil up, the MS will eventually come back to surfice...
17. Which is different from the LttP design, which is different from the TP design. Yet all of those are supposed to be the same 'Blade of Evil's Bane'...
2. I suppose I can believe that. I believe that the WW writing was probably in development perhaps. All languages change in order to make more sense.
4. He did deny it, but I don't have the link to the old quote. But I need a link of yours or else it's just like mine.
5. Ah but note how the sages don't seem to be referenced in FSA. As a matter of fact, they have been ultimatly replaced with new sages who don't have any links with the old ones.
6.1 You must check the size of every Hyrule we have visited and noticed how small they are compared to FSA's. For all we know there was an ocean beyond those mountains. Also, are you impling when we were in tribes our continents weren't continents?
Another thing I must note, if the Hyrule in FSA is truly the one we see in the AT then where is Catalia? That is LOZ Link's homeland. If Hyrule is an island persay then that would mean that Catalia doesn't exist.
6.2 Perhaps I'll agree with that.
7. Did you see the ending of FSA? Zelda clearly stated that they were sealing Ganon into the Four Sword. The Four Sword was found in the dark world. They probably had sealed him in the sacred realm somewhere out of game.
8. You say that Alttp link and OOX Link are different. However, then if OOX happened while LA was occuring then that would mean that two Link's were in existance. Now unless your timeline states differently, that would mean that two Links were present in the world.
12. They call themselves maidens but does that mean Saria is not a sage? Does that mean that Ruto isn't a sage? They are basically sages but named differently.
13. Then you will prove me correct that they are the same mirror. They work the same and lead to different or the same place.
Why would a mirror exist to a Dark World that shouldn't exist? The Dark World was purified at the end of WW with the death of Ganondorf. (If it was purified by his death in Alttp then it must be the same for here.)
14. Proof that there are two tridents.
15. True, if we followed art style it would probably make this easiers.
16. Deflooding would not bring a dark tower above to the ground. In fact deflooding would probably make the tower go underground.
17. How do we know that they are the same blade of evil's bane? It never was stated that more or one blades was made at the time.
However if they are the same then their location should also be in question, in WW it was left on Ganon's skull and in TP it was left in a forest. In the adult timeline look at LOZ and Aol, there was no Master Sword there. There was no master sword needed to defeat Ganon, yet in Alttp there was a Master Sword in the forest.