Firstly, I'd like to ask you the following. How many times have you been able to pin down the Mafia 100% of the time? Wait, I think can answer that, it's 0 isn't it? Even Jo, one of the most experienced here, stated that she only has a 50% success rate in finding Mafia. Infact, if you go by the last game I played, I had a 0% success rate and I was a townie...There is one issue I would like to address as of now. The godfather.
So far, only our mods have been the godfather (Hanyou, in Mafia Round One, Kybyrian, in Mafia Round Two). I'm not saying that one of the mods playing is the godfather, but I'm just pointing out that every godfather before has been a mod.
But, the bigger thing I had in mind that I would also like to address is that everyone who has a special night ability. Which means that we can only lynch the godfather. Which means we always have to make use of our lynching ability. Which means, we need to analyze people more often, and interpret from their posts and use our judgement to tell if the person's scum or not...
Coming Soon: THP's Analysis Special. Join us analyzing scum.
Now, the first person who is on my list of people who strike and struck me a suspicious is Durion. And I am doing these in the order of which they were from PJ's list of members playing.
And we begin THP's Analysis Special on Durion.
At first glance, he seems just like a humble townie, but this post:
Really caught my eye, after kokirion said he started the debate, which he kind of did, but he was replying to a post of kokirion's. That post earned him a spot on my Mafia note taking sheet. (I'm trying to avoid the mistake we did last round, so I decided to start taking notes)
Then I took him off, since he defended himself well, at least in my opinion...
And he continues to seem just to be a townie to me, helping out the confused, and answering some questions.
Time passes, and we go into voting.
Durion voted for Awesome. And he was a townie. Could just be a dumb/noob mistake, but with his experience with mafia, I was in high doubts, so I put him back on.
See below for the section about Hero of Time for why I think this post was suspicious and he did give Axle his eyes. And Axle was a townie.
Gave kokirion a FoS. And he was a townie.
Truthfully, if this was Durion's first game playing Mafia, I would've just assumed that he was a noob at this game. But he's not. I'm not sure if it's a coincidence, but I'm going to give him a solid HoS.
And no, that was not an edit. I swear. (I just noticed that every time I preview my post, it counts as an edit, but am I not allowed to preview my post?)
And I know better from editing my posts in Mafia, so
Also, your evidence has no grounds for me being the Godfather. I was suspicious of the people that died, so what? I think there are many others that were suspicious. If I was to go back and investigate all your posts, I think that my conclusion would be that you don't add anything to the discussion, which is usually a scum tactic. Wyatt pulled it off pretty god damn well last round, and a few other Mafia did it. So what proves that you aren't the Godfather?
I'm not really accusing you of being scum, I'm just defending myself here.
Also, I am going to back THP up with the previewing post thing. If you preview your post, even if it's a EBWODP, it's counted as an edit, even if you don't actually post anything.