I hate not hearing from inactives, so I'm just gonna try doing a mini-analysis on two wagons and explaining my revised suspicions from there.
"Wagon analysis? That's a scumtell!"
Well, I need to do SOMETHING rather than wait for an inactive to post.
*
cue some non-Ace Attorney music.*
- - - - -
D1 Vote Count
karu (1): Ayano Keiko
funnier6 (1): HyrulianEVAN
YIGAhim (3): Rubik, Minish_Link, Ryuken
Stormageden (3): Ragnarokio,
Bok Chan Sama, Doc
Doc (1): funnier6
Rubik (1): YIGAhim
Not Voting: Stormageden747, karu
D2 Vote Count:
Ayano Keiko (1): Ragnarokio
Ryuken (3): Bok Chan Sama, Minish_Link, Doc
HylianEVAN (1): funnier6
karu (1): Rubik
Not Voting: Ayano Keiko, karu, Doc, HylianEVAN
- - - - -
I've been suspicious of
Ragnarokio because of the fact that they joined my wagon after I responded to their post without explaining why. They also acted like this during D1 as well when they voted me. However, they were
the first person to vote for Stormageden D1:
Unvote, Vote: Stormageddon
i like lynching inactive players
This was also the first vote where they gave a legitimate explanation, and I doubt scum would unvote someone just to start another wagon on their scumbud D1.
Now people have discussed Doc bussing, which I still don't agree with due to them being the last person on the wagon and the one to tie the votes. I've already explained why I don't think Rag is bussing due to them being the first person to vote for Storma. Consider this: the possibility that the scum is actually the second person on the wagon:
Bok Chan Sama.
Yes, I know that I have them as a
Town read, yes, but lemme explain.
I still haven't caught up but I just noticed this is your only post. Do you have anything to contribute? Saying you're here isn't enough.
Unvote
Vote: Storma
I'll read through everything and post more thoughts soon.
Just posting this here for reference. This is clearly a pressure vote to try to get them to talk, and I think it's a clever way for scum to hide themselves on a wagon against scumbud in case more votes start to get placed on said scumbud.
My hunch on them has started growing stronger D2 due to them placing the first vote on Ayano immediately after the announcement, then switching to me after I voted for the same person. They've pursued me pretty aggressively this day, too, which I initially read as a Townie trying to corner someone they think is scum. However, I don't like their offer to send everyone back to the real world to do lynches. I know I already mentioned some reasons, but I'd like to add to them after having more time to really think about the offer:
1) The Mafia would also be free to nightkill a player and be able to kill them off.
2) It would also negate the potential Town roles that have powers specific to Dreamscapes. Say, for example, the
Dreamer.
Inception Rule #3 said:
Every dreamscape has a person called a "Dreamer". They act as a pseudo-Dreaming God within their dreamscape. The dreamer is chosen at random and will be notified if they become such.
This is the extra edge Town has over Mafia in Dreamscapes along with the ability to live another Day after a standard lynch/nightkill, and that's part of why I thought D1
while I was analyzing the rules that this game would actually be stacked against Mafia.
3) This is just a personal opinion, but I think doing that offer would make this game less fun.
Do you really believe that's all that will happen? Won't that just clear whoever gets sent back that day as town? It feels like nightkills from the mafia will be sent to limbo but I could be wrong. It just seems useless for the mafia to only be able to send one person back a level every night.
Bok seems to be really worried about the Mafia having powers that could screw Town over in the Dreamscapes, which makes me suspicious considering we already hit one out of their three scum already. Of course, we don't know what powers Mafia have, but the way Bok has been talking about them makes me think they know more than they're letting on. I'll reiterate that I think this game is actually a bit stacked against Mafia because of the lynch/nightkill effects in Dreamscapes and the Town having a Dreamer, but I'd like to hear what everyone else thinks about the way this game is balanced.
For now, though...
Vote: Bok Chan Sama
"But you voted Keiko because they were inactive! Now you're changing your mind?"
Well, they haven't said a single word since the RVS vote for
an entire game day, and considering they haven't asked for a replacement like a few other inactive players, I don't feel comfortable lynching them. I want to vote for someone based on the information I've read/interpreted from their posts. This is why I felt more comfortable voting for Yiga than Storma and was surprised to see that Storma flipped scum.