I said 8/10.
Graphics get an 8. It looked like TP and WW had a baby, which I was okay with, but they were a bit bright for me. I loved the intricate designs of certain parts though (each region was thoroughly thought through, and the enemies were creative). It was appealing to look at overall, but Twilight Princess remains my favorite.
Enemies a 6.5 0r 7. I didn't like how they all did the same damage: one heart, always one heart. They were also not very creative, way too many species of bokoblin for my liking. I did like how they often dropped treasures though. That was fun. Almost all the enemies, though, could be killed by my classic "hack and slash" technique that's not really a technique at all. I appreciated in TP how there was a variety of skills required, especially like Darknuts and using shield bash/helm splitter combo. You had to think, whereas in SS I didn't really.
Bosses get about a 7. Ghirahim was awesome, and the one that required the most skill and effort from me: plus he was HILARIOUS!! "It just fills my heart with rainbows!" "I am ANGRY! SO ANGRY!" Some of the other bosses, like Koloktos, were well-thought out also and required a lot of thought, time, and effort. Others still like Tentalus or Scaldera didn't present as much of a challenge. I loved the boss design, however. for all of them. I agree with whoever it was that said "They got harder until after Koloktos, when they got easier". Except Ghirahim II and III. The Imprisoned just annoyed me after a while...it was a nice added challenge when he got arms but when he could FLY, and had a tail? That was just too much. Plus it was really annoying just trying to get on his back, and my WiiMotionPlus didn't like to do vertical slashes.
Controls:
8. The different ways to use the bow, and the using the wii mote to swing the sword, was fun--but it didn't register my thrusts well, or my upward vertical slashes.
Dungeons: again 8. I loved the design but some of them were just too easy for my liking: Fire Sanctuary, Ancient Cistern. The design of those two was by far my favorite, though. I wish they;d gone on longer. The Sandship with all the timeshift stones was great. Lanayru Mining Facillilty I hated. Mostly because of Beamos. and the maze like quality to it. Skyview Temple and the first fire temple were just boring, in my opinion.