Pen
The game is on!
I'll just say that we should lynch one of All Might or Pen today. One of them has to be lying, I believe. I know I've been pretty cryptic about this, but it's a bit difficult to explain. But if All Might is town Pen is almost certainly scum, and if Pen is town than All Might is likely scum.
What is it that makes you suspect All Might that much?