Congratulations on doing something!I said what I said. There's a reason I mentioned how many pages we're in or what is currently being talked about with no in depth analysis to back it up.
Rather than forcibly making up anything, even something weak, I'd rather see more concrete discussion driven by interactions and opinions on interactions vs making something up.
If anything it is detrimental to some town to make something up and try to push it *just because*. You're not going to solve the game off of it D1.
Also, what is this DW?
Like, what is going on here? Because YOU made it a point to purposefully push for something -- anything -- for the sake of discussion. No matter how small. Isett brought up a discussion point. NAI or not, it's a discussion point that gives you something to talk about as has been seen already with some people chiming in.
Seanzie's whole "vibe" thing to start it off is already a nonstarter for actual solving wrt to Isett. The bulk of Seanzie's post going into more "concrete" stuff is another matter entirely since, by Seanzie's words, Isett's whole discussion setup is NAI -- something that while scum can do town can also do (especially if you're looking to talk about anything D1 which hey, you were). So it is questionable to me that Seanzie would start with a bad vibe followed by a "concrete" observation of a NAI point regarding Isett's NAI action. Strictly speaking, you're going to get opinions on people both good and bad, and on a topic that is NAI in the first point, well what else would you expect? But overall it's discussion that it generates which is what you wanted.
So already both you and Seanzie are coming off weird to me.
You for the complete 180 simply because Seanzie had a "vibe" that gets "concretely" rooted in a NAI point, and Seanzie for pushing said vibe on a NAI point.
Like, is that what you, in particular DW, were looking for when it came to *anything* that someone felt? Even something as flimsy as a vibe like Seanzie talked about?
Because all I see from Seanzie is entirely speculation with no concrete founding in it due to the entire focus being rooted in something that is, as Seanzie contended, is NAI in the first place.
I do not expect to solve the entire game Day 1. But I expect people to try their damnedest to based on what there is available anyway, which will give more material to read based on going into the next days.
And yes. I did do a 180 on that post. Its not as though the town vibes I was getting were strong. And I really think the fact that Isett focused. Yes, Isett brought up a discussion point. Yes, I think that having discussion points in the thread is a good thing. But Seanzie pointed out Isett focused on their discussion point as a discussion point, and that is not remotely its primary merit. Clearing people is. And the more I think about that, the more I see that misfocusing of discussion benefitting scum much more than town; if they focus on it as a discussion point, rather than as a method of clearing people, than there's a chance other's will during the discussion overlook it as a method of clearing people as well, instead focusing on what Isett focused on: discussion generated, which on that subject, won't be great for getting good reads. And again, I overall agree that the general vibe of Isett's post is similar to first posts I've seen from some scum before.
The read I'm sheeping isn't strong, and I'm not planning to vote Isett unless their further posts also look bad.
And yes, even just a flipping vibe is a viable answer to "anything" at this stage of the game. It's early D1. What do you expect?