I liked PH compaired to ST because It was like this.
PH: "Yay! I have a boat! I can now go wherever I want! WOOHOO!"
ST: "Woop-dee-doo, I have a train, I can go only on the TRACKS"
Traveling across plains of grass and snow were two things; Boring and slow.
It felt clausterphobic because I could only go on the tracks, NO WHERE ELSE, exept stops.
I would have to say that ST is my least favorite zelda game.
PH although was fun, exiting, and full of adventures. I liked wind waker, and I felt that PH was a mini version of that specific title.
PH was fun because If you wanted to go to that island, You would draw the way, and POOF, you would already be going.
I loved chasing after the ghost ship just for fun, i also liked sailing to beatle, I liked how you could draw your way to something!
But the temples were a bit, umm, easy. But it was always fun to play around with the boomerang!
So in my opinion,
ST: Fun, but quite boring.
PH, Fun and exiting.