Game Thread Fate/ZD Mafia

[Silverfish]

Sigh. Things just keep getting more and more tangled up. Feels very much like a catch 22 here.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Sigh. Things just keep getting more and more tangled up. Feels very much like a catch 22 here.

Well it's a toss up between Pen and All Might probably. Also your role is so insane and leaves like 0 accountability, and sounds completely useless tbh.

 

[Silverfish]

Well it's a toss up between Pen and All Might probably. Also your role is so insane and leaves like 0 accountability, and sounds completely useless tbh.

Me? Completely useless? Noooo. Couldn't possibly be.
Yeah. I envy those of you who get to do things. But don't think that You're completely off the hook just because you took me off of your hook. Conspiracy corner is still looking at you.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Me? Completely useless? Noooo. Couldn't possibly be.
Yeah. I envy those of you who get to do things. But don't think that You're completely off the hook just because you took me off of your hook. Conspiracy corner is still looking at you.

Do you honestly think it'd be beneficial to summon dead town players when for scum it'd be more useful to just summon any dead player regardless of alignment?

 

[Silverfish]

Do you honestly think it'd be beneficial to summon dead town players when for scum it'd be more useful to just summon any dead player regardless of alignment?

I mean, if a dead town was voting another town, yes. And you haven't proved you can't summon scum spirits. You just proved you can summon at least Minish.
I see the point you are trying to make. But. There is always more than one avenue to explore, and staying in the obvious avenue isn't working.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

I mean, if a dead town was voting another town, yes. And you haven't proved you can't summon scum spirits. You just proved you can summon at least Minish.
I see the point you are trying to make. But. There is always more than one avenue to explore, and staying in the obvious avenue isn't working.

I did prove that I can't summom scum though, I used my power on Rag and the vote count was updated - Rag wasn't voting. I did it with Minish and it worked. To still consider the notion that I could summon scum in light of this is just being ignorant of an established fact.

 

[Silverfish]

I did prove that I can't summom scum though, I used my power on Rag and the vote count was updated - Rag wasn't voting. I did it with Minish and it worked. To still consider the notion that I could summon scum in light of this is just being ignorant of an established fact.

I might have gotten sidetracked by the missummoning of Minish.
Wait, no I didn't. I got sidetracked by the using of the same name twice. So if I understand right, you use your servant name to activate the vote? Or is that the name of the ability? Cause I thought it was the name of the person you were trying to summon, but that was debunked once I actually looked at previous posts and didn't assume. I tried to google it and just ended up more confused. Now to double check Rag was voting, since we're actually looking at things.
Wait, what's this?

Unvote, Vote: Giri

Rag's last vote was on Giri, unless I seriously messed this up. A dead player. Rag was also on Ex D1, which is another dead player, just in case you can choose days. Which means that vote wouldn't show up/count, if what you say is true. Unless, again, I'm misinterpreting something and you really can summon a dead vote. So. I wanna hear what you have to say about that.

 

[Ronin]

My servant is King Hassan of the Assassin class.

King Hassan is very...interesting and it explains the killing role to boot. However, the thing I'm not too sure on is his alignment. He could go any which way, although in the anime he had his own agenda.

I'm All Might, a Lore specialist

My servant info: Rider (Iskander)

Okay, I can actually get behind this. SMS has effectively proven his innocence with Ionian Hetairoi and disproven my hunch that he might be masterminding things. You say that things boil down between me and Pendio but you shouldn't quite rule out Silver yet either. His amnesiac claim seems like a pretty safe thing to hide behind, but I guess the one saving grace that he doesn't have a killing role [that we know of].

@All Might did you ever share your Master (ZD) name?

I didn't have to because you already did. Emperor Jimmu is both the Master and the Servant. That's what it means to be a Demi-Servant, in essence.

 

[Pen]

SMS is looking more and more like Town. Well done if you aren't because then you've got me fooled in that case.

All Might seems to be genuine about being the SK. I'm just curious if he was honest about his win condition. If he doesn't win alongside Town when the Mafia is eliminated there might not be a great chance at a Town victory. But if All Might was Mafia I doubt he would have claimed to be SK and been so bold as to take credit for kills he didn't perform. Seems too risky. So I do at least believe his SK claim.

That leaves Silver. I'm honestly still the most suspicious of him, partially because of the process of elimination and partially because he is supposedly Pendio. I do think that a No-Lynch is tactically beneficial to us today though. As long as All Might doesn't kill tonight and we assume the Mafia kills someone, that could narrow it down enough to help us find the scum.

Vote: No-Lynch

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Ngl, the fact that Silver is still willing to leave any option on the table for a lynch today is pretty scummy. Comparitively, Pen being ok with a no lynch looks townie.

I still think a no lynch is our best option, I think Silver should be shot, but ultimately it's up to All Might who he picks to shoot, I just think after recent developments, Silver looks pretty scummy, and Pen less so. A No lynch doesn't help a Mafioso, for a Mafioso any lynch besides their own would be a good lynch today, and Silver's mindset is the epitome of that.

Anyway, Silver and All Might should target each other, if Silver doesn't target All Might we lose anyway and that would suck because I honestly think Town deserves this win. There is also the chance that either one of them is bulletproof, which would explain Pen's 1x Strongman Shot, hopefully we can just lynch whoever remains in the next day phase if all goes according to plan.

 

[Pen]

No. All Might should not kill tonight if we do a No-Lynch today. That's too risky and then we might as well lynch someone today instead.

Question is if we can trust All Might not to kill anyone tonight.

 

[Silverfish]

Silver and All Might should target each other

I see you have made up your mind. I shall still try to remind you that I can literally do nothing but talk at night. But you never addressed the issue that made me look scummy to you. Is no one going to care that Rag's last vote was on Giri? That since Giri is dead, rag's spirit can't vote for him? I don't like the fact that you ignored that. I don't like that you're suddenly certain of me. You've done a lot of flip-flopping about me this game. First on day two, where you literally voted for me, and then left me completely alone D3. Granted, I don't know you well, but I would have thought you'd go after me on D3 as well.
I find it funny that the only person I trust is a serial killer. And I also hate that I'm starting to believe the absurdity that is Pen's claim over yours.

A No lynch doesn't help a Mafioso, for a Mafioso any lynch besides their own would be a good lynch today, and Silver's mindset is the epitome of that.

A No Lynch does help a Mafioso. It makes it so that all they have to do is take out any town and they win, assuming the SK can win with both down and scum equally. I'm telling you this is our last stand.
I mean, look at this. We NL today. Night falls, lets say AM doesn't shoot anyone. Mafia takes out a town. We're at 1-1-1, which should be a mafia-sk win. Let say mafia is nice and takes out the sk. Best case, were at 2-1. Or how about AM and the mafia take out people? 1-1, mafia-sk wins, or 1-1 town-sk wins. If they shoot the same person, it's still 1-1-1. And if by some miracle the mafia and the sk shoot eachother, town wins. So. Do you like those chances?
If we mislynch today, yes, we've pretty much lost. But I will fight to go down fighting and earn our win than leave it to blind chance with too many variables. Mafia has the upper hand, lynch or no lynch.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

I see you have made up your mind. I shall still try to remind you that I can literally do nothing but talk at night. But you never addressed the issue that made me look scummy to you. Is no one going to care that Rag's last vote was on Giri? That since Giri is dead, rag's spirit can't vote for him?

It doesn't matter if who they were voting for is still alive or dead, if I could have summoned Rag it would have worked but it didn't because I can't. I could have summoned Ex to self vote and it would have worked because he is Town, lol.

 

[Silverfish]

It doesn't matter if who they were voting for is still alive or dead, if I could have summoned Rag it would have worked but it didn't because I can't. I could have summoned Ex to self vote and it would have worked because he is Town, lol.

Hm. Okay.
I don't know how much to trust that, but okay. Logic algorithm has been updated.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

I see you have made up your mind. I shall still try to remind you that I can literally do nothing but talk at night. But you never addressed the issue that made me look scummy to you. Is no one going to care that Rag's last vote was on Giri? That since Giri is dead, rag's spirit can't vote for him? I don't like the fact that you ignored that. I don't like that you're suddenly certain of me. You've done a lot of flip-flopping about me this game. First on day two, where you literally voted for me, and then left me completely alone D3. Granted, I don't know you well, but I would have thought you'd go after me on D3 as well.
I find it funny that the only person I trust is a serial killer. And I also hate that I'm starting to believe the absurdity that is Pen's claim over yours.

A No Lynch does help a Mafioso. It makes it so that all they have to do is take out any town and they win, assuming the SK can win with both down and scum equally. I'm telling you this is our last stand.
I mean, look at this. We NL today. Night falls, lets say AM doesn't shoot anyone. Mafia takes out a town. We're at 1-1-1, which should be a mafia-sk win. Let say mafia is nice and takes out the sk. Best case, were at 2-1. Or how about AM and the mafia take out people? 1-1, mafia-sk wins, or 1-1 town-sk wins. If they shoot the same person, it's still 1-1-1. And if by some miracle the mafia and the sk shoot eachother, town wins. So. Do you like those chances?
If we mislynch today, yes, we've pretty much lost. But I will fight to go down fighting and earn our win than leave it to blind chance with too many variables. Mafia has the upper hand, lynch or no lynch.

We're screwed no matter what though, really: if we lynch the Mafioso All Might wins. If we lynch All Might the remaining Mafioso wins. Best chamce scenario we have is the SK had a seperate wincon that doesn't take away from a town win.