Dungeon Tournament (Deathmatch)

[A Link In Time]

Round 1 was just too much and I was busy.

But for Round 2 my votes went for

Forest Temple>Skyview Temple
Forest Temple (TP)>Forbidden Woods
Spirit Temple>Goron Mines
Ancient Cistern>Tower of the Gods
Fire Sanctuary>Lanayru Mining Facility
Fire Temple>Earth Temple (TWW)
Earth Temple (SS)>The Sandship
Snowpeak Ruins>Arbiter's Grounds

 

[Trio the Punch]

My life's goal is to make sure that no Twilight Princess dungeon takes the prize in this death-match. They are undeserving.

I voted Forest Temple, Forbidden Woods, Spirit Temple, Ancient Cistern (hardest choice I've ever made), Fire Sanctuary, Fire Temple, Earth Temple, and Arbiter's Grounds.

 

[MonkeyFightSquad]

i do not know how to vote

anceint cistern ftw

 

[JuicieJ]

My life's goal is to make sure that no Twilight Princess dungeon takes the prize in this death-match. They are undeserving.

Uh...OK? That's kind of biased and uncaring, don't you think?

i do not know how to vote

Just click on one of the battles and vote for which one you want.

 

[Trio the Punch]

Uh...OK? That's kind of biased and uncaring, don't you think?

Not really. I don't mean they are undeserving because they are from Twilight Princess, I just don't think that any of those dungeons are good enough to win.

 

[JuicieJ]

Not really. I don't mean they are undeserving because they are from Twilight Princess, I just don't think that any of those dungeons are good enough to win.

Ah. OK, then. I misunderstood.

Still, the statement was a bit harsh.

 

[HylianPancake]

ATTENTION!

Round Three has started! http://nintendocastle.com/dungeon-tournament-round-three

Voting ends this Wednesday, and then it's time for the semi-finals!

 

[cucco002]

A bit late, but here is round four if someone is interested

http://nintendocastle.com/dungeon-tournament-round-four

 

[JuicieJ]

There's no reason the Ancient Cistern should be beating the Forest Temple of OoT. In fact, it really shouldn't have gotten this far at all. It's has a great concept, but, as Axle has pointed out, has a pretty poor design. It's basically just running around the same areas and doing the same things the entire time and has little originality taken from the originality of the concept it has. It just wasn't executed that well in comparison to how much potential it had.

 

[MW7]

There's no reason the Ancient Cistern should be beating the Forest Temple of OoT. In fact, it really shouldn't have gotten this far at all. It's has a great concept, but, as Axle has pointed out, has a pretty poor design. It's basically just running around the same areas and doing the same things the entire time and has little originality taken from the originality of the concept it has. It just wasn't executed that well in comparison to how much potential it had.

I agree. I think there were some people that just voted for all Skyward Sword dungeons since they are fresh in their minds. I raised an eyebrow when I saw every SS dungeon made it past the first round- they're good but not that good. Ancient Cistern and the Earth Temple (I'm aware it's out now but the fact it won a single round shocked me) at least are not great by any standards IMO except aesthetics or concept. Fire Sanctuary and Sandship are pretty good but I wouldn't call either one the greatest 3d dungeon.

 

[JuicieJ]

Oooh, Forest Temple and Ancient Cistern are tied.

 

[Tetra's Wink]

How the hell has the fire sanctuary got this far? I'm sorry, but it was a boring, below-average dungeon IMO.

 

[JuicieJ]

How the hell has the fire sanctuary got this far? I'm sorry, but it was a boring, below-average dungeon IMO.

I don't agree that it was boring, but I do agree that it shouldn't have made it this far. Stone Tower Temple should be in its place.

 

[Tetra's Wink]

I don't agree that it was boring, but I do agree that it shouldn't have made it this far. Stone Tower Temple should be in its place.

Well for the final 4, I LOVE sandship and forest temple. I liked ancient cistern but it wasn't my favourite. As for fire sanctuary, it just doesn't live up to these 3 IMO. Found it unmemorable

 

[JuicieJ]

Round 5 has begun. Sadly, it's the Fire Sanctuary and the Ancient Cistern. >_>

http://nintendocastle.com/tournament-zelda-round5-poll1