Do I like Twilight Princess? Yes. I love Twilight Princess. It's Zelda. I love Zelda games above all others, with perhaps a few exceptions.
It is, however, not my favorite Zelda game. It's actually one of my least favorites (which still places it way up there on my top games of all time.) Perhaps some of the reason is me being stubborn. See, before the games release and even up until I actually played the game, I had serious issues with it. The realistic style, the disturbing creatures, the dark story... it turned me off because I didn't feel that was true to the "spirit of Zelda." I didn't feel it was a turn the series should have taken. Especially with the fact that the game was rated T. I still don't like that.
But having played the game (almost all the way through now, too,) I feel my opinions of it starting to improve. It is a great game. I'm also warming up to the style, although I still prefer a more stylized look for Zelda (not necessarily the toon style, but not so realistic.)
Minus a little nitpicking here and there, my only real problems with the game are:
-Too easy. Especially the bosses. They're ALL great in concept, but horribly easy.
-Style and atmosphere. I feel it's a little too dark and disturbing. Many people say Majora's Mask is darker, but I really don't see it that way. Some of the key elements of TP that make it so dark for me are the disturbing creature designs, execution and direction of the story, music and atmosphere, etc.
-It felt kind of rushed to me. Areas like Gerudo Desert and Snowpeak were very brief, and there were next to zero NPCs in both areas. Worst of all are the items. Most of them are hardly ever used outside the dungeons you get them in.
-Fanservice. I personally felt that a lot of the aspects of the game were thrown in to make the fans happy, and I can't help but think that if they didn't do this it would have been a better game.
So, I still have my problems with it, and I do like all the other Zelda games I've played more than it, except perhaps for Wind Waker. But I still love the game. I think it had some really good ideas, especially with the dungeons, bosses and items, I just think it could have been better. Perhaps if they spent more time on it?
Oh... and I guess I sort of resent the Wii version because the fact that they mirrored the game seems... weird and pointless to me. That's basically the main reason I got the Gamecube version instead.
It is, however, not my favorite Zelda game. It's actually one of my least favorites (which still places it way up there on my top games of all time.) Perhaps some of the reason is me being stubborn. See, before the games release and even up until I actually played the game, I had serious issues with it. The realistic style, the disturbing creatures, the dark story... it turned me off because I didn't feel that was true to the "spirit of Zelda." I didn't feel it was a turn the series should have taken. Especially with the fact that the game was rated T. I still don't like that.
But having played the game (almost all the way through now, too,) I feel my opinions of it starting to improve. It is a great game. I'm also warming up to the style, although I still prefer a more stylized look for Zelda (not necessarily the toon style, but not so realistic.)
Minus a little nitpicking here and there, my only real problems with the game are:
-Too easy. Especially the bosses. They're ALL great in concept, but horribly easy.
-Style and atmosphere. I feel it's a little too dark and disturbing. Many people say Majora's Mask is darker, but I really don't see it that way. Some of the key elements of TP that make it so dark for me are the disturbing creature designs, execution and direction of the story, music and atmosphere, etc.
-It felt kind of rushed to me. Areas like Gerudo Desert and Snowpeak were very brief, and there were next to zero NPCs in both areas. Worst of all are the items. Most of them are hardly ever used outside the dungeons you get them in.
-Fanservice. I personally felt that a lot of the aspects of the game were thrown in to make the fans happy, and I can't help but think that if they didn't do this it would have been a better game.
So, I still have my problems with it, and I do like all the other Zelda games I've played more than it, except perhaps for Wind Waker. But I still love the game. I think it had some really good ideas, especially with the dungeons, bosses and items, I just think it could have been better. Perhaps if they spent more time on it?
Oh... and I guess I sort of resent the Wii version because the fact that they mirrored the game seems... weird and pointless to me. That's basically the main reason I got the Gamecube version instead.