It's by no means a bad game, at many times I loved it but there were many flaws that but it down very low in my list of Zelda Games. The Game was just dark, and not in a good way. Some games use the dark mature graphic style well like Skyrim or Residant Evil. But for a Zelda game! No. The style just felt bland to me, there was hardly any colors which made me feel sort of depressed when I played it. Maybe if the game added some colors and made the graphics more bright it would have been a good style.
The story of Twilight Princess wasen't bad but wasn't very good either. You start with a very epic entrance where you find the whole land engulfed in twilight. But soon the games story just got the same. Find some tears turn out of a wolf. Now your for some reason the hero. Go and get some random relic. Find more tears. Do this over and over again. More wolf play, you find the sword. Then Ganondorf is just brought squeezed into the game which in my opinion was not important to have. Then we learnd about Zant which is cool and then the end. Not a very good story. The story is just plain and boring.
The side content was more or less abunch of collecting and Minigames, and that's by no means bad. But I like Side quests like Skyward Sword and Majoras Mask. Those games had in depth side quests that were not just collecting and Minigames. Let's take Majoras Mask for example. We have the regular Minigames but we also have, helping peaple defend farms, helping a couple who are engaged, and so much more. But Twilght Princess, find souls and bugs and play a game with a creepy clowns in Lake Hylia. Not how I want to spend my time.
Those are most of the flaws but there are many good things. The dungeons even though being way too easy we're very fun and unique. But the best thing is Hyrule Field. The world is huge and there is a lot of fun things to find and explore. Just riding my horse through the open fields was by far the best part of the game.
So in a list Twilight Princess might go number eight or seven. One being the best. So in the end, Ok game.