Throwing this here:
We went from blantantly anti-town to no further contributions.
Should read vote*You love to post when people post for you.
Note I said I had no leans, and then voted for you.
Do you really think I think you're scum at this point in time?
Just so we're clear, you think me and Rag are scum?
Sure:can you give examples of each?
She asks anyone with any sort of action to claim. Something like that always seems insanely scummyOkay, since actions are one shot I think it may be best if everyone claims if they got a question right yesterday and give any potential info they may have. Though if you'd get more info by asking questions first then definitely do that.
I think it's fairly likely SMS isn't mafia. I had a motion detector shot that I used on him last night, and he didn't move. I chose him because he was a low poster, and because I thought it was very unlikely he didn't answer any of the questions yesterday so I felt he wouldn't be moving due to using a one shot item he got.
This was when I first suspected her, I feel like this is a pretty good answer to my criticisms.???
I came into today saying he wasn't likely to be mafia because he didn't move during the night. I've mentioned SMS like two or 3 times, and those were with talking about everyone else as well.
She lists out all the night actions. On the one hand, that could be genuine townie trying to solve. I think it seems more like a mafia member trying to get town cred.Okay so the night action claims:
Minish motion detects SMS (No movement).
Mapel sends Chevy motivator shot.
Seanzie sends Chevy pineapple.
Rag tracks Mapel (visits Chevy).
Killjoy roleblocks Chevy.
That's 5 actions.
We can assume Storm probably was telling the truth about getting a doctor shot, so that's 6. And there were 8 questions so we're missing 2 actions.
It's possible Kirino had one, though he might have not been as quick as some others.
I know SMS either didn't have an ability or it was a passive one because he didn't move. So that leaves Viral, Ex, Chevy, and Zinger. It's possible Chevy had one but it didn't go through because he was blocked by Killjoy.
Do we know if mafia can also get stuff from in thread questions?
This is another example of what I feel like is cwac, she's breaking down the pineapple incident when it had kinda already passed.Seanzie and Chevy are not likely scumbuds because of the pineapple.
Chevy and Killjoy are probably not likely scumbuds.
I don't feel Chevy and Mapel are scumbuds because of the motivator/pineapple mix up. But it is possible Mapel got a motivator shot, gave it to his scumbud Chevy, Chevy got a pineapple and they just assumed that was the motivator shot. But I don't know how likely that is.
Rag and Mapel could be scumbuds because tracker claim on a scumbud is easy. But I'm going to just think for now they're not aligned.
She asks anyone with any sort of action to claim. Something like that always seems insanely scummy
She lists out all the night actions. On the one hand, that could be genuine townie trying to solve. I think it seems more like a mafia member trying to get town cred.
This is another example of what I feel like is cwac, she's breaking down the pineapple incident when it had kinda already passed.
Truedat, I didn't take that into considerationNormally you'd be right that it's pretty scummy. But the setup of this game is unique in that we don't stay one role. So it's better to out any information we have, because scum can't go "oh they're the cop, we can kill them" or "they're the doctor we can block them". We're constantly switching roles around and gathering information. Especially since our abilities can't be held onto.
Fair, I talk outloud to myself about everything, not just mafiaThis is a fair assessment that I can't argue much against other than to say that it's mostly me trying to sort things out for myself. Like talking outloud, so trying to figure out who could be lying about actions.
I see that now, I didn't really study that message enough.This breakdown was something I had be considering for a bit. In that I knew that certain people didn't seem likely to be scumbuds with eachother and so I was working it out to narrow down PoE. It helps for if one of those people flip scum so we know the other likely isn't also scum.