Best Zelda Game Poll 6: Wind Waker Vs Twilight Princess

[DarkestLink]

That one guy is right, we ll know TP will win. It's like OoT on steroids. It provides adventure and enjoyment in a manner that looks similar to OoT, while adding it's own twists and charm.

Wind Waker is a poorly animated cartoon that fails to live up the other 3d titles. The enemies are stupid, Hyrule and its races have been mutated into a freakshow, the dungeons alos fail to provide the epic, challenging, and serious tone of he others titles. WORST ZELDA GAME EVER. It cannot compare to the legacy it was handed.

Ehhh I disagree...this is a pretty close and active one. They're neck in neck.

 

[Austin]

The enemies are stupid

I don't mean to be rude but, define "stupid" here.

 

[iloveghirahim]

Wind Waker.

 

[ShadowDiety]

If you ever compare any Zelda game to date with Twilight Princess, my answer will always be Twilight Princess.

 

[masterSword2]

My vote goes to The Wind Waker. I consider both TWW and TP to be fantastic games. In fact, WW is my favorite game, and TP is my 2nd. WW was my first LoZ game, and I played it at an age where I had no idea what to expect from a video game, so I may be a bit biased. I still have a number of reasons I think WW is superior though.

WW's soundtrack is amazing. The way it meshes with the game is just perfect. Dragon Roost island is a great example of this. I find that I have a lot more fun playing through the dungeons than in TP. WW provides many interesting characters that make the game's story a lot more involved.

In general I find that TWW is just a lot more enjoyable. Some people may complain about the sailing, but that never bothered me. It's just a part of the adventure.

 

[Heroine of Time]

The Wind Waker, for sure. I love both games a lot, but nothing can compete with the thrill of adventure I get every time I play TWW. I love its graphics so much more, too. Oh, not to mention that Twilight Princess was so much easier for me than TWW. Seems like everyone has differing opinions about that, though. XD I wrote a post comparing the two a while ago, so I'm too lazy to type it up again.

I'm going to be really disappointed if Twilight Princess wins again. At least they're pretty close!

Also, in response to the OP... this isn't really the place to argue over this, but I don't think the parry was invincible at all. Using it at the wrong time could leave Link seriously open to attack, especially during the final fight with Ganondorf. The only flaw I found with it was being unable to control which form of the parry Link uses, since sometimes he'd end up rolling around a Moblin and its spear would sweep the ground and hit him, much to my frustration. I don't see how its any more "invincible" than the Hidden Skills.

That one guy is right, we ll know TP will win.

But The Wind Waker's winning right now. ^^

 

[JuicieJ]

But The Wind Waker's winning right now. ^^

The poll keeps going back and forth.

 

[Heroine of Time]

The poll keeps going back and forth.

Yeah. I was just about to edit that out of my post, but you've quoted me so I guess I'll leave it. XD It's a really close poll! This is so interesting! I'm really curious about what the final results will be.

 

[Ventus]

Yeah. I was just about to edit that out of my post, but you've quoted me so I guess I'll leave it. XD It's a really close poll! This is so interesting! I'm really curious about what the final results will be.

15 a 15 you know? I didn't know many people actually preferred TWW over TP! xD

 

[Fede-hime]

Wind Waker. I have more complaints for TP than I do TWW. Namely the escort mission. I HATE escort missions. I can't even begin to count how many times the carriage went up in flames because I was busy felling enemies.

Considering how much people like to complain about the sailing, that was actually one of the parts I loved most about TWW. Not so much KORL himself; he's a talkative dingy. But the sailing was nice.

 

[Maxxy]

I can tell that Wind Waker will win.

 

[fused_shadows]

Twilight. Princess. Is. The. Greatest. Game. Ever.

'Nuff said.

 

[ihateghirahim]

Go Twighlight Princess! Go Go Go.

 

[Link2792]

Hmm tough one. Windwaker really didnt have that many dungeons that stood out except the earth and wind temples and on a lesser note the forbidden forest. Although all dungeons in tp were easy(except snowpeak ruins), i give the edge to tp. Also the soundtrack to tp was pretty decent with themes like hyrule field, boss battle with blizzeta, lake hylia, and midnas lament. The only song i care for in tww was the boss theme for molgera. TP ftw!!

 

[Painmaster212]

While TP was good it just felt like Oot and MM again wear about WW felt more like the old school Zelda games once again so id have to go with WW even though neither of these make it in my top 5.