You are objectively wrong. Puss n' Boots is objectively Antonio Banderas. I mean, objectively come on. The objective truth is objectively staring us right in the face, objectively.
Ok i'm some kind of Shrekgamelover so i think that in all of these games the best on is Donkey. He's into the irony, battle, smart-talk and the Dragonlady. It makes sense especially in SuperSlam ( https://rawg.io/games/shrek-superslam ) - he's the best one for fighting. Amen.