Rachel
be vigitant
Wow. But I guess the night kill wasn't much of a surprise, since we lynched our Doctor. Clearly Atticus has been a threat to the Mafia for most of the game, starting the lynch on Raindrop and nailing the Godfather, and probably at least one or two others.
Alright, let's break this down. I'm almost positive either Mido or Timeless is one of the remaining scum. I don't think both of them are. Timeless and Keeseman were fighting a bit earlier I think, but it's possible that it was a townie-townie fight. GWaF's death proved JJ's innocence to me, since she went after him so aggressively. Heroine of f Time and Dr3W21 could definitely be mafia, but could also be town...Dr3W21 hasn't posted enough, really. We found that he diverted attention away from himself to TheMasterSword, if I recall correctly.
Rishian: Before, I was confident that he was townie, but he hasn't posted since almost a month ago. Once he was sure that we thought he was townie, he may have tried to fade into the background so no one would notice him. He'll probably pop into the thread after I post this to defend himself and say he forgot about the game, and probably move on to accuse me of being scum.
4 Townies Left, 3 Mafia Left
Probably Town: JJ
Can't Tell: Mido, Timeless, Heroine of Time, Dr3W21
Probably Mafia: Rishian
A Note on Timeless:
Keeseman turned out to be town, so in my opinion it's more likely that Timeless is scum than Mido. It could be some
I won't place a vote until I hear what other people have to say. If we do end up voting for Rishian and he flips scum (I think he is) then we can assume that Mido is townie (because Rishian voted for Mido, unless this was some sort of mafia tactic) and Timeless very likely to be scum.
If Rishian is Scum:
Probably Town: JJ, Mido
Can't Tell: Heroine of Time, Dr3W21
Probably Mafia: Timeless
If Timeless is Scum:
Probably Town: JJ, Mido
Probably Mafia:
EBWODP: Ack, I pressed enter by accident and the post submitted my bad.
Continuing my Note on Timeless:
It could be some sort of mafia tactic and Mido might be scum, I don't know. Looking at the fight between Timeless and Keeseman, it looks like Timeless had some weak reasoning, but I think he might have been trying to get the game moving.
Continuing the bottom of my post:
If Timeless is Mafia:
Probably Town: JJ, Mido
Can't Tell: Heroine of Time
Probably Mafia: Dr3W21, (Rishian)
I added Dr3W21 because if Rishian and Timeless are scum, then there's one mafia member left, and I honestly think it would be between Heroine of Time and Dr3W21. I find Dr3W21 more scummy because of his lack of posts and diverting attention from his lynch to TMS. Heroine of Time was a little tentative with her votes, but at least she voted I guess.
Again, this is all my opinion, I really hope everyone else says what they're thinking, or if they agree with me. We absolutely have to get this right. Let me know if I made any mistakes or if you need clarification.
Probably, but I sure as hell won't let this day end in a No-lynch.
(The Living: 9)
Atticus
Dr3W21
Heroine of Time
JuicieJ
Keeseman
Mido
Rachel
Rishian
Timeless
That's my list for right now. I think I also have a pretty good idea on who the doctor might be, but I'm not releasing that theory. Green means Townie. Red means Scum. Gold means I'm unsure of their true affiliation. I want to either pursue Mido or Keeseman. If one of them turns up scum, Timeless is innocent.
I'm also hoping that Axle modkills Keeseman. It sounds like a bad thing, but I'm almost certain he's scum.
Alright, let's break this down. I'm almost positive either Mido or Timeless is one of the remaining scum. I don't think both of them are. Timeless and Keeseman were fighting a bit earlier I think, but it's possible that it was a townie-townie fight. GWaF's death proved JJ's innocence to me, since she went after him so aggressively. Heroine of f Time and Dr3W21 could definitely be mafia, but could also be town...Dr3W21 hasn't posted enough, really. We found that he diverted attention away from himself to TheMasterSword, if I recall correctly.
Rishian: Before, I was confident that he was townie, but he hasn't posted since almost a month ago. Once he was sure that we thought he was townie, he may have tried to fade into the background so no one would notice him. He'll probably pop into the thread after I post this to defend himself and say he forgot about the game, and probably move on to accuse me of being scum.
4 Townies Left, 3 Mafia Left
Probably Town: JJ
Can't Tell: Mido, Timeless, Heroine of Time, Dr3W21
Probably Mafia: Rishian
A Note on Timeless:
I mean, all I can bank on, is the fact that you guys believe my earlier roleclaim, and I can't point anything out, besides the aforementioned Mido jumping in to defend Keeseman. Until someone dies, we're at an impasse.
Keeseman turned out to be town, so in my opinion it's more likely that Timeless is scum than Mido. It could be some
I won't place a vote until I hear what other people have to say. If we do end up voting for Rishian and he flips scum (I think he is) then we can assume that Mido is townie (because Rishian voted for Mido, unless this was some sort of mafia tactic) and Timeless very likely to be scum.
If Rishian is Scum:
Probably Town: JJ, Mido
Can't Tell: Heroine of Time, Dr3W21
Probably Mafia: Timeless
If Timeless is Scum:
Probably Town: JJ, Mido
Probably Mafia:
EBWODP: Ack, I pressed enter by accident and the post submitted my bad.
Continuing my Note on Timeless:
It could be some sort of mafia tactic and Mido might be scum, I don't know. Looking at the fight between Timeless and Keeseman, it looks like Timeless had some weak reasoning, but I think he might have been trying to get the game moving.
Continuing the bottom of my post:
If Timeless is Mafia:
Probably Town: JJ, Mido
Can't Tell: Heroine of Time
Probably Mafia: Dr3W21, (Rishian)
I added Dr3W21 because if Rishian and Timeless are scum, then there's one mafia member left, and I honestly think it would be between Heroine of Time and Dr3W21. I find Dr3W21 more scummy because of his lack of posts and diverting attention from his lynch to TMS. Heroine of Time was a little tentative with her votes, but at least she voted I guess.
Again, this is all my opinion, I really hope everyone else says what they're thinking, or if they agree with me. We absolutely have to get this right. Let me know if I made any mistakes or if you need clarification.
Last edited: