Should add David to that list. He's been on my radar for a while, especially after the whole "cop should totes say something, nowait, cop shut up" thing. Mostly a gut feeling, but it feels to me like he was trying too hard.Let's face facts here, chances are that one of the people posting detailed posts in this game and generally playing well is gonna be Mafia. That means me, Nicole or Xinnamin, as far as my memory recalls. I'm going to have a re-read and form some conclusions.
With that being said, I'm also a bit suspicious of Djinn. Every game has its share of lurkers, but often a lot of those lurkers are just people who are less experienced and hesitant. Not saying that excuses every less experienced member from posting, it's just a general trend. When an experienced player lurks for most the game though, that raises my suspicions, and Djinn has only posted 4 times so far.