2006-Okami
2007-Bioshock
2008-Fallout 3 (no contest)
2009-Demon Souls
2010-Halo Reach
2011-L.A. Noire
2012-Borderland
2013-GTA V
2014-Titanfall
My own list and boy was it hard to choose just one for each year. Personally I would have Fallout 3 win every year cause it's amazing. Last year had...