Search results for query: *

You both were arguably the mvps for your respective teams so I can get behind this. ;)

I literally sabotaged my own wincon by stomping sun that night lmao. Gg Well played scum, sorry for being totally unable to decide if I was scum or town siding lol

unvote vote: johnny

Aaaaaahhh

Ninjad oof unvote vote: legacy

Vote: Johnny I have to do this, sorry. I know it's bold, but ugh this eod is annoying.

11 new pages. 5 minutes left. I'm busy at work but I'm here rn. Tell me who to vote.

We already had like 10 pages dedicated to this lol. Also as it turns out, there's a hockey game tonight so I'm anticipating work is going to be busy. I'll be around for another hour or so but it's unlikely I'll be around for eod.

Oh I see, yeah that makes sense. My point still stands then.

At this point I don't know. I'd like to say no, but I'm more unsure than I was at start of day.

How exactly would town still win if you die? Mikey being town doesn't matter, it's mylo. Is this a slip?

Honestly being reckless with softing and such just kinda makes me feel like Legacy is town, because mafia would be more careful especially on a day in which they can win. Also, everyone remember that mafia insta wins at the end of the day if the votes stay where they are, since they can very...

I get getting annoyed. Hell I did earlier quite openly. There is a lot of "content" that I've missed this day (word used loosely because the majority of it seems to be just continual rehashes of the same stuff) so I may not be as well informed as everyone else. For that reason, I don't even...

I want what's best for the town. Right now I don't know what that is and I skimmed through a lot of the mechanical mumbo jumbo today so I may not be fully caught up with what's happening. Who is your number 1 scum lean? Is it still Mikey? Why have you not voted for him yet if so? Tbh I think...

You don't know my wincon.

Also Legacy stop overreacting. You say you're not town lock but your reactions say otherwise. You're acting like you should be universally townread. If I said I scumread one of your town leans would you react the same way?

You do realize that I could just vote you and give an easy opportunity for scum to jump on if I was really siding with them. Like are you for real rn

When I first brought up the framer, I did so under believing I had some sort of idea to what Sun's role was. However, the events of today have caused me to rethink that and, especially considering the character flavour others described earlier, I'm willing to believe he was just a Miller. All...

I'm not sure I would say Sun was universally scumread at the end of the last day. I had him at null, and I know Mikey at least was town reading him.

tbh I'm feeling that too. I tried reading the mechanical discussion that took up like 15 pages and comprehended next to none of it but it feels like just a lot of CWAC. Though, is there a reason why you're locktown? Did I miss something? I think you are, but is it objective for anyone other...

It's possible, of course, that parity isn't the mafia wincon. But under the assumption that it is, I feel like a no lynch is just as risky, perhaps moreso, than lynching a top consensus scum read.

But 3-4-1 + town kill in the night = 3-3-1 (parity). Lynching me yields the same numbers. I think if we lynch a townie, it's an insta-loss. The reason it's MYLO rather than LYLO is probably because there is still a way for the mafia kill to be stopped. Given that, no lynch just doesn't seem...

The Miller speculation actually makes a lot of sense, and if that's the case then Sun could very well have still been the scum kill.

Given the numbers, I'm pretty sure a no lynch (or a me lynch) gives the same result. Unless I'm mistaken, lynching scum today is absolutely essential.

Wait I think I got the numbers wrong in my head, I get what you're saying. Wouldn't we be in lylo rn if that was the case though?

Except in this case, the game has the numbers that even if that hypothetical scenario was to occur, with a mafia lynch today the game is guaranteed to continue another day if the vig were to holster. Whereas with my lynch, there's a very good chance mafia wins tonight.

I don't think it can really be mylo with only 2 scum unless there's a second indep, so there must be 3. So yeah, I think lynching scum today is pretty much essential.

With 8 players left, assuming a scum team of three, whether you lynch me or not, if the mafia kill goes through then tomorrow will be parity. Given that, the best course of action is to lynch mafia.

Why would scum rubik come forth with an incorrect result on the townie they just killed Like what lol

This sounds like a Framer, which I don't think scum would frame and kill the same person in the night. But at the same time it would have to be a pretty lucky frame. It's a rather confusing situation. The other possibility is that yeah, the letter giver is a mafia rule that gives insane...

I don't think sun fan was the mafia kill. I obviously can't explain why, but it's not the first thing that will likely come to your minds. Hence why I made my first post above.

If we say something like "roleblocker please be the first to vote today" would that count as a claim?

I feel Libk more than Rubik but I'm not really feeling either of them tbh.

Basically what I'm trying to say is if we assume 3 scum, if the vig misshoots then it'll be LYLO whether I get lynched or not, unless a wolf gets lynched. If you lynch me, or a townie, or even a no lynch, vig should probably holster to avoid LYLO.

No lynch is also an option, though I'm expecting a lot of resistance to this idea. If you lynch me, and 2 townies die at night, it'll likely by LYLO, minus one vote (me). Whereas if we no lynch, it'll still probably be LYLO tomorrow, but then at least there is one more vote. The poe is narrowed...

If rubik is a wolf I'll eat my shoe. Ok maybe I'm not that confident so I'll eat Bok's shoe instead. We have a little over 2 hours. I'm not gonna self pres because I'm really not convinced about Rubik, plus by the rules he'd be lynched anyway at the current tally (I think).

My lynch is counterproductive but I can't really stop you. I still think Rubik is town and Mikey probably is too. I can see both town and scum motivations for being discreet about my alignment and then outing me later, but I'm kind of feeling inclined to townread Johnny for it at this time. I...

Fair. For what it's worth though, I have been genuinely trying to scumhunt this game. I had a slow start because I wasn't sure how to approach this as it's kind of new territory for me. On this you'll just have to trust me as I unfortunately can't prove it without lynching scum.

Games like Gravity Falls or Pen Mafia X prove this to be completely untrue.

I think my townreading of 2 confirmed townies and avoiding the Rag lynch should prove enough I'm here to cooperate. But I do realize all I can do to prove it otherwise is give my word.

Sorry for getting emotional earlier btw. I've been playing as if I was town so it is a little frustrating to see people comparing to my scum meta, plus sleep deprivation puts me in a really bad mood lmao.

Bok walked into my room and told me alignment claims are fine so I'm indep. I have a very specific wincon but can't say more than that. It's of my own benefit to hunt scum though. (made sure I wasn't saying too much first so dw)

I don't know if I can answer that without breaking the rules. @funnier6 @Mafia Host do alignment claims count as claims?

Rubik I honestly think is town, and Sun Fan is seemingly the only one whose vote isn't from meta. Johnny I was null on during D1 but I feel like his contributions this day have been fairly proactive. If there is a wolf, I'd say it's him, but I don't think it's wolf led.

If I get incorrectly meta lynched when people townread me for "reminding them of a game in which I was scum" I'm retiring from mafia forever. If you townread someone because of their content, then you should townread them period. Scumreading someone because you want to townread them but they...

lol twas just an observation, not a read. @Legacy of Smiles it's the fact that he never came in with an explanation/excuse, just placed an RVS vote, made one or two decent posts, then disappeared as it started picking up. Seemed like he was trying to just be under the radar for the most part.

I've spoken about him a few times in this thread already, but mostly it was his complete disappearance once the game started picking up. He posted once D2 and honestly I can't tell you by memory any of the content of said post. There's been tons happening in the game, while when he stopped...

If he wasn't replaced I would vote for Mido rn, but that's not really fair this close to EoD. I'm considering a Johnny vote but I feel like I need to look at his posts again. I didn't like his Chevy vote and I don't recall anything from his D1 really screaming town, but he has been more...

Do you have anything more than just reminding you of my play in ssb? Because if not I'm not taking you seriously. Be more specific, what about my play in this game reminds you of ssb?

No this is correct, I was mistaken. Went back to check cuz the whole nap thing ain't working out.