Search results for query: *

I gotta say though, if I had to choose between someone who had claimed Jailkeeper and someone who had claimed Vig, I probably would have gone for the former. Mafia Vig was a nice touch, though I still gotta give credit to the scum team. Y'all played well, and your Johnny kill seemed really...

Oh btw my roommate told me the other day his cat's name is Zuko. Make of that what you wish. Anyway, this was a fun game. I am quite appalled by my own performance in this game, but I'll deal with that when I have time to hate myself for it. The ending was quite intense and the curveball of the...

And thanks to you for hosting the game that first got me into mafia!

@ExLight how come you cleared minish after the Watcher died? If you'd said you got a red check on me you probably couldve pulled off a faster win.

That was risky killing Storm. If he really was the stump it wouldn't have worked. More from me later. Definitely wasn't expecting a double mafia kill.

Which has nothing to do whatsoever with the post of mine that SMS quoted. It's SMS and funnier. I'm calling it now. Anyway time for work. I'm just going to go ahead and do this now since I won't be able to respond for 9 hours or so. Vote: SMS

I was going to vote SMS because of his convenient Vanilla claim but then I remembered the previous Korra games also included Vanillas. But I'm really thinking now that its SMS plus one of funnier or Minish.

Aaaaand looking back, what SMS responded to was when I said either of Minish or funnier could be scum, not both of them. So his response still doesn't make any sense.

Oh you're right I'm a dummy. So a funnier-Minish scum team is out of the question. But still, one of both of them could be scum. I'm off to work now. Toodles. Y'all do as you will.

Unless that was an SMS slip up, as if he is scum with a non-investigation proof godfather that's the only way he would know Ex's cop check would be definitive.

> Godfather is alive > "Cop check is definitive and 100% clears someone as town" alrighty then You didn't think that through very well did you? Guess you could make the argument that the godfather may not be investigation immune, but with a scum team of 2 idk, that just seems a little weak.

Honestly I'm really genuinely believing now that one of Minish and funnier are scum. Maybe with SMS. Either way, they've both been discounted as town this whole time and I'm not sure how I feel about that.

@A Link In Time can you confirm that we're not in -LO today?

We're not in MYLO. Alit would've announced it if we were. Unless you know something we don't? Also yeah, what I picked up on about SMS was the possible Vig soft. The confirmation that he's not puts him back in the PoE. I really highly doubt theres a 3 person scum team. Even if Storm was in it...

You can keep trying to solve you know. No need to give up now.

Simply because I just thought up the plan afterward. Pls answer my question pls and thx

I'm actually trying to come up with ways to solve this and win now. Sorry you think my idea is stupid but if Storm actually can be lynched I really think it's a solid one. Tell me why it's stupid, aside from the obvious possibility of him being lynch proof.

Wait can tree stumps even be lynched?

Tell me why that's a bad idea.

And I'm actually being serious about this and would like to hear what everyone else thinks.

Alright then. What if we lynch Storm today? If he's scum, great. If not, at least all the living townies will be able to vote in LYLO.

I agree then that All Might should claim. There is way too much happening rn.

Vote All Might then and it doesn't have to be. Lynch me if I'm wrong.

Your eyes will remain dry then.

Idk how much my own opinion is worth, but FWIW, All Might is the common denominator in most of the scenarios I can see, and he can be pretty good at blending in as scum.

I found one particular SMS post close to the beginning of Day 2, is that what you're referring to? If so I need to throw one of my crackpot theories out the window. I get your point now. I was thinking of it purely from a numbers perspective, but having a vig on the town side would help balance...

Thinking about it, SK funnier would kill in the PoE if it led town closer to victory. :suspicious: Screw it I'm too tired for this rn, gn folks

Ex + Minish scum team? Idk, my morale has already taken a massive plunge in this game so I'm just pulling this out of my ass. My ass is smarter than my brain tho.

@ExLight do you have any results to share?

Also will we ever play a mafia game where meta isn't used to formulate every single read? Some people aren't that great at recognizing changes in meta and that causes great confusion.

Oh wait, I think I'm getting it. But if it's what I'm thinking, I'm not calling him town for sure. And if it's not, then yup I'm a proven idiot.

Is there? I must have missed it, because I don't really get why he's been discounted all this time. Can you explain it as if I am a 5 year old cuz sometimes I feel like I have the brain of one. I swear to Mases if theres an SK in this game you all owe me a thousand cookies. Also, a PoE shot is...

Minish. I said it in my first post today but I can see how you missed it. I was kinda hoping she would have been able to verify it but she must have gone to bed before I came in.

lol Possible. This is the only way I can see him being scum because being voteless in a 2 person scum team seems incredibly weak, especially if there really is no SK. I just don't think 2 scum and a Survivor is very balanced in a game of 13. Although the evident lack of a Cop and Doctor could...

Is it really that outrageous to assume that Ex actually is a Tracker? Tracker + Watcher in place of Cop seems pretty balanced to me. Although that kinda throws my crackpot theory of you being SK out the window. And admittedly, I mostly skimmed the thread so I probably did miss some stuff...

The only question I asked is why the vig would shoot knowing it easily could have resulted in LYLO if they misfired. And you're not wrong tbh. I don't know him very well lol, I'm looking at it as if I was in his position... which probably isn't the greatest perspective if I'm being honest.

Also I think Ex is town. Assuming there are 2 scum left, I don't see Ex tying it up like that if he is part of it because he should know that would paint a target on his head today. What questions?

I did read the thread but thanks for the tip!

Here's a hot take: Minish and either All Might or SMS are scum while funnier is SK. ...lol even I can't help but laugh at that one

If I could I would friend

Well, unless I was roleblocked, which I didn't really think of.

Naturally the day began an hour after I got to work. How come SMS or funnier can't possibly be scum? Anyway, Minish I targeted you last night. I figured if you were scum you would be the likely one to carry out the kill, and if you're town you would have been a good scum kill. I had a 2 in 9...

I'm at a red light who should I target

So... instead of breaking the tie, you make it 3-way forcing town to choose between even more people? Wew lad

You'd rather have a no lynch? At least my lynch would provide more information. If I didn't know any better, I'd say you're scared of how people are going to think of you when I flip town.

Unvote ties will get us nowhere

If you're investigative and had info to share, after sugar coating it for a while there comes a point where it's best just to claim.

Ok, bringing up roles like that is a huge red flag, especially when you know he targeted funnier and he claimed to be investigative.

No I get that. I'm just asking why you didn't hard claim when you were asked to? Part of the reason I was hesitant to claim is because I knew it would be taken as NAI. Do you feel like it would have been the same scenario in your case?

Ok, so lemme get this straight. LG Watched funnier and discovered he was visited by Ex in the night. Did Ex hint towards knowing funnier's role, or act weird towards him during this day phase?