Oh, I thought of another one.
Paintings that change when you're not looking at them.
There are a few in games like Amnesia, but even when the context is not sinister it creeps me out. There's a painting in Thief: Deadly Shadows that changes for a nice reason, but even that makes me all...
There are certain things that I encounter in video games that always creep me out. They make me feel uneasy every time, without fail, and I'm wondering if there's anything that creeps the rest of you out every time you see it.
For example, any time I have to get in a lift and there are doors on...