Okay a strong contender for no. 5 is Xenoblade Chronicles. That one's really close to nostalgic already for how long it's been around. It even has that old school look and feel and the characters and story are whole worlds of endearing. I can definitely see it occupying the 5 slot in the not so...
Usually I can fill a Top 5 list, but my history with video games only goes as far back as the gamecube. I got into gaming late but took to it with a passion. But I haven't really got the long history to build up nostalgia for nes, snes or genesis/sega era games.
One exception is Myst, my first...