i was having a bit of trouble understanding the whole logic behind this survivor thing ex and hhh are talking about, so i'm just going to explain how i was understanding it and if i got anything wrong feel free to correct me.
if i understand it right, ex claimed to hhh in a dm that he was "the...
ok i'm caught up.
what killjoy said idk what to think about. i kind of feel like it might be best to take it with a grain of salt. he must have said it cause he thought it would benefit scum to. i would guess that probably he at least wouldnt have named both scum like that assuming there are...
i looked back at when amber was killed and killjoy was the first to post after. he posted this about 6 minutes after rag's post announcing her death.
it seems a bit artificial to me. immediately putting the blame on someone else, when i dont really see a reason to suspect ex in particular...
is a "necro" like a common role or something? people were talking about it as if it would make ex more suspicious if he seemed like one but i couldn't find anything about it from google.
hhh going after ex so strongly has felt like it might be self pres to me. since the suspicions on them originally were both bcs of the ogs wagon.
i kind of agree. it almost seems like he chose that in reaction to amber being daykilled or smth. like what other reason would he have to suspect...
rag said bonus votes don’t count towards hammer. im wondering rn if hhh or killjoy were already aware of that or were actually trying to hammer ex and thought it would work.
although rubik said something...
hm. you had unvoted 4 times before you voted exlight, and there was 1 bonus vote on him and your vote. so, one of those maybe was worth 1 and the other was worth .4? you hadn't unvoted at all before you voted rubik and he had one bonus vote and your vote. he...
oh that makes more sense. i was wondering whether it would just be the zombification on its own since it wouldn't be very useful until someone ex had put it on happened to die. hm. i mean i guess it could have been useful if someone had claimed to have an investigative role or something too...
i mean, that could go either way. if you were scum maybe you were worried that might happen so you tried to push people to hammer. i think if there is only one wagon and a lot of people are on it it would be more expected for someone to vote on it in reaction to pressure to vote than for the...
i guess i read it as you implying that. since he was the only person with votes on him and was one vote away from a hammer. who else were people going to vote.
i see, i misunderstood. i thought "he" was referring to ex.
i was thinking what he was saying was a scumslip during the day was this:
if you look here https://www.zeldadungeon.net/forum/threads/ms-paint-mafia-u-pick-edition-day-3.76639/page-17#post-1440015 this is where he said it.
i dont think this was a scumslip though.
uhh. maybe i didnt explain it...
i read back and both hhh and ex do seem bad at the very start of the wagon. ex seemed to vote ogs initially because ogs said ex made a scumslip and hhh because jamie died at night. hhh also joke voted ogs during the night, and ogs jokingly accused ex of being scum at night because ex said "meow...
i feel like hhh looks worse than you but i'd like to hear why they think you're not town @HangryHangryHippo. maybe im missing something. i thought your case seemed fairly reasonable so i'm not seeing it as AI rn.
it would also help to confirm your trustworthiness obv which is useful. im already reading you as town but still. idk how realistic it is though it's just an idea.
not that i think it has no value though. you personally know that he's town and can discuss things with him now obviously. idk if he has any more important information, but if he did he could tell you. or if you ever get someone else with your ability they could too.
hmm. i don't know ogs very...
alright, i think i might as well vote ogs out. i agree with the logic that we need to see his role at this point to get anywhere. he said himself he wants someone to, and he'll probably be voted out anyway when the day ends. might as well not have to wait 20 hours.
vote: OGS
i skimmed through OGS's earlier posts and thought of some things that i want to ask about.
@OGSniper i think what you said originally about your role was pretty different from what you're saying about it now. you said that both town and mafia would lose if you died? or were implying it offered...
also dont we already know that information for most people? we posted in the sign up thread. hm. i mean, that ability is there for a reason though. if it's actually real. we probably already know whether most people started the game as a 'human' flavor. so learning that information might not be...
do you think rubik would have motivation to lie about it, if he was the thing? do you know what the thing's win condition is?
so rude :(
is this meaning that the thing jumps into someone who had targeted when it is killed via an ability? so if the only person who had targeted it is dead, it...
i see. thank you for summarizing it. hm. i think if i had to vote rn i would vote for him. your argument makes sense.
to be honest, hhh's initial push for ogs felt a bit weird to me and i think that made me hesitant about what you were saying too. i re read it closer and you seem reasonable to...
hm. i see. by "the way he's fearmongering us" do you mean "we're guaranteed to lose" like what he was implying earlier or "it will hurt town's chances of winning" like he was saying later?
i will also just post what i have been writing so far.
this is a lot of text to try to understand and most of it seems like arguments about really minor things? not that im trying to defend ogs necessarily, i'm just having trouble understanding this whole conversation. there's like 5 different...
all these references about previous games are kinda confusing too tbh. it's been hard to understand what people are talking about sometimes wrt/ killjoy.