Max, investigate whoever you want. I think by now ME would have been targeted and recruited by mafia if that were his alignment but his gameplay has been consistently very town from what I've seen and I want to keep him around. He could be third party but that's the only other option and I find...
Okay, so obviously I don't want the vig to target a townie in a perfect world, but isn't ex's statement a little dramatic? Assuming four mafia, it's 14/4, even if there were three kills we would still be outnumbering them 11/4. Worst case scenario. Why would that mean we instantly lose?
I KNOW I'M SORRY :kawaii::kawaii:
Me no likey. Wanting to kill someone who's almost verified town is just. As. Anti. Town. We need all the people we can trust in this game, especially if we keep mislynching.
I'M SORRY I'M STUCK ON MOBILE AND IT SUCKS TO TYPE :kawaii::kawaii:
There are a couple of people I'm not sure about
Tomorrow I’d be up for lynching LG, funnier or ME (as policy lynches). Maybe Zinn if someone else has a convincing case against them.
I’m in no way planning on voting...
I'd like a full 24 hours before this happens, 12 at the very least. Some of us still don't have our roles and I don't want to catch them off guard again. Plus gives us more time to talk and think. Night chat is fine, but I'd like a bit more than that before we let the mafia take another shot.
Minish, can I
I don't see any point to doing this. Ex's role I think is totally vindicated by the mods at this point now, and I see no reason to doubt Max's claim currently, besides that it's strange to have both a cop and a role cop on town's side.
Will get on that soon, hopefully within an...
So this means we have ME and Deku as basically cleared, right? And according to Tristan, funnier is "no threat to town", and since his death validated his claim, I'm definitely willing to believe it for now.
What is gladiator?
Yeah, I would have kinda expected the normal cop to be the target since I could kinda see a wagon forming on Tristan today, and it would be more likely that the normal cop would be healed by a doc.
How likely do you think that a big/sk killed Tristan, and Ex blocked the kill on Max?
Also...
Vote: No Lynch
I think I completely trust Max at this point. I hate the timing of his claim, but that doesn't mean I don't believe it. It sounds like Ex targeted him without role knowledge last night as a means of protecting him. Sounds like his role protected him, but made it so that the two...
Unvote
Okay I'll switch my vote over to
Vote: Max
I feel slightly bad about him so I'll vote him with ME. I can detail a bit more about why I think that when I get out of work, I know this isn't going to go anywhere but I hope it'll give you some more data to work with
Guys please no more role talk until the next day. It's right before night and mafia will be making their target soon I don't want to give them something to work with
OH CRAP DAY ENDS IN 30 MINUTES
Vote: Kerest
I'm sorry guys, I know it's a an easy and safe wagon but I didn't realize day was going to end when I woke up and need to put my vote somewhere and I'll try and iso people after work
Okay, I can't stand for this kind of thesaurus abuse. This post legit looks like it jumped off of r/iamverysmart. We asked you for a defense and you literally said "Kerest has insane insight". Literally the only reason I'm not voting you at this point is if this has to do with your role. As Moe...
I'm definitely going to wait until at least in-game tomorrow to give him my vote. I don't like lynching inactives, it's cheap and almost always unhelpful.
I was under the impression that anyone could be recruited and didn't put any thought into this situation. Can anyone who's played with this role before or @Spiritual Mask Salesman verify anything about this?
Also does anyone have a current vote count?
A grand total of three iirc - Moe the Moblin, Spiritual Mask Salesman, funnier6
Also sorry for my relative inactivity so far guys, I'm almost completely stuck on mobile until mid next week and I've been reading the thread, but trying to post on mobile is one of the few things I seriously despise.
Okay so I'm gonna try posting a reads list for now because all the cool kids are doing it. Arranged in order of town-scum.
Town
SMS - I see no reason to doubt his claim especially as Zinnie seems to be backing it up. It's possible that they're just scumbuds and covering for each other, but that...
Tbh between this and Zinn's statement that he/she had the same strategy, I'm having second thoughts about Ex. I still don't find his plays entirely pro-town, but I'm starting to think that's just his playstyle. I had similar thoughts about Moe when I first played with him but now I find his...
I'd prefer to wait for now and not press funny boy for any more details at the moment. I trust him enough for now unless he really wants us to lynch him.
Tbh I don't think we're going to have any "real" evidence to build a strong case until the end of today as most of us only just found out our alignment (and assuming third party roles, some probably still don't know), and very few if any know our role iirc.
Like I said, I just see this as the...
I just can't get believe you would target yourself. With there potentially being at least three killing roles, maybe more, there's still a dangerously high chance of ending the game for yourself. I doubt it really happened. And it's all too easy to say you did and claim that you must be a...
What's restless spirit? I assume a third party role because context.
Also I'm town, but I don't know my role. Guessed doc, because it's the first thing I thought of. I suppose that means someone else is doc then.
Yeah, I was wondering how much we could take seriously since no one knows their alignment, and it looks like that's all that's been going on all day. Do we actually gain anything from a lynch though?
(Also I'm actually going to sleep now)