I'm always reasonable lol, most people realize it's NAI for me and it's why funnier scumreads me when I'm town (: Interesting that that was the main reason for scum reading me. You gotta play with me more often my friend.
I like how the mafia were basically the only ones who didn't catch on lol. I did make it quite obvious though, between deliberately not actually including funnier as town on my reads lists and giving some blatant hints towards his role, even doing all but say it outright when I mentioned Eye of...
Good game.
I was told when I died that I had a chance of being revived so i continued to follow the game, and I'm glad I did because it got quite intense towards the end. I genuinely wasn't sure what to think of Moe, but I was really surprised you guys didn't kill Rubik. When he claimed backup...
Without explicitly guessing town, there's no way to know 100% whether you truly are town or not. That's all I meant, you're reading too far into it.
On that note though, highly unlikely as it is, an indep role cop could indeed make sense, especially in this setup. Or at least it does to me and...
Nah that was a silly point to bring up and I'm sorry that I did. Next time I'll read the rules better and try not to get silly ideas that only make sense in my head.
Still think it's dumb to doubt Max's claim tho.
I'm going to bed now, goodnight!
Hi guys, I just got off work, what did I miss?
Saw some pings so I'll answer them rq because I get why the confusion is a thing.
Instead of "wording", I should've said "formatting". Max said his result was "DekuNut is a townie" or something along those lines, in terms of format it's the same...
Moe and Sun are like a sitcom about a couple who bicker all the time where Sun is the self conscious wife and Moe is the husband who pokes and prods her for ****s and giggles and it's very entertaining.
Regardless of when it happened, a counterclaim would be inevitable. I've seen this scenario play out multiple times and I don't recall ever actually seeing a fake cop claim (don't quote me on that though, my memory bad). All Max would be doing by fake claiming is writing his own name on a death...
Max had no way of knowing there wouldn't be a counterclaim. That's where the risk is, and in this case, the risk would not be worth the reward if he was scum.
Also, as was established late day 2, mafia can't accidentally kill their teammates. Mafia targeting mafia simply adds them to scum chat...
Ik it's not a slip, I used the word loosely, but what he said about the Miller. I'll admit it wasn't a super townie thing to say but it's not super surprising for me coming from Moe.
Disagree with that last line, but I'm not sure how many people will back me on that.
But... you literally told him to claim
I'm not sure what other kind of response you were expecting out of him.
Oh ok, so he claimed before you said that but you hadn't seen it. Fair enough I guess.
Should be...
Sigh. I know I'm late to this discussion, but this post right here led to 8 pages of role speculation and I'm sad.
And on that note, why did you claim again? You basically had no pressure on you.
On another note, why are people being so quick to doubt this claim? There is no way for Max to...
OK? So the mafia would know his alignment. But how would he know. I don't see in there where they say that the person targeted would also be informed of their alignment.
What do you mean by this then? I feel like we're on roughly the same page but I'm a little confused. Based on what you're saying, you're confirming that ME is dangerous because he could know he's mafia and just keep playing it off as if he still doesn't know. Leaving him alive could lead to...
I use the term loosely to mean "flip-floppy".
*ugh react*
I mean I guess? idk, I find it hard to read people either way when they don't make sense.
So would you lynch him today then? Would you place a vote right now? If so, I would join you.
I was thinking of Cult Leader earlier, not neighbourizer. I should've realized neighbourhoods could contain mafia members as one of the people who hosted the OoT game at Bulba which included scum within the neighbourhood. I'm just a dum dum idiot I suppose. This does void my read of Zinn...
Here's a barebones reads list for now. Will elaborate when I can.
Town:
SMS
Minish
Ex
Hero
funnier - this one is just here because he's not a danger to us
Null
Moe - he's playing like he usually does but I think he'll forever be a null slot for me
Sun Fan
Kerest
Rubik - slight town lean...
Well yes, but it was the middle of the night and I had an incredibly busy and somewhat lousy day at work.
#badexcusesarebad
That wasn't the reference! :P if anything, LG should know what I was talking about.
Yeah, this makes sense.
Without confirming or denying anything, I will also say that...
Alright, here's where I stand at the current time.
I'm not convinced Ex is scum. I think he's a bit too reckless to be. He was reckless in the one other game I've played with him and he was town in it.
I don't like ME's plan to not guess, but I do believe he is being genuine. That being said...
Disagree. There's no need for the mafia to know who has the balls. That's giving them information they shouldn't have.
What gives you this idea? Just out of curiosity.
Look back through my posts (there aren't many of them, shouldn't be too hard). I've been making subtle hints. See if you can spot them and figure it out.
I'm a little confused by this. Simply using a successful action doesn't give you your full role PM, at least it didn't in my case. I figured...
Funnier, please tell me you understand me. I just want us to be frens so we can hang out together and listen to cool tunes like Eye of the Tiger. You like one hit wonders?
If you play for town, there's no reason for us to kill you. Even if you play for mafia, I doubt you'd pose much of a threat to us.
I hope based on my somewhat cryptic wording you're able to pick up a little bit of what I've been putting down. And if you get it, you will understand why I am so...
I'm really confused. With no restriction on claims, why would you be modkilled? I'm honestly struggling to understand you right now.
For what it's worth though, I never thought you were mafia. And i discourage anybody from voting for you, there's no need to.