For reference, here is a list of people who have softed in some way:
Ex
SMS
Me
Echo (3p)
I did kinda soft in a way, but y'all wouldn't figure out my role just from what I said. Lol.
Ex's claim checks out, and SMS's is provable. Poy is green, which doesn't necessarily prove his alignment but I don't want to lynch somebody who is green today.
Eh, I'm not giving Poy a pass for being a green check at this point when there's almost certainly godfather and the PoE is closing in. Especially when Poy has done nothing to make me town read him.
I think the main point is that said you didn't necessarily find Ex's post worth scumreading him for, but still kept drawing attention to it, in a way that made it seem like you were pushing him as a potential lynch target without appearing to do so. Moreover, you do seem to be saying that it's suspicious now.
I wasn't scumreading him for that specifically because it wasn't AI, but with other stuff it could have looked bad. Plus not reading things really frustrates me, which I think has been apparent even in these last couple of games. I'm always gonna harp on people for not reading stuff to hopefully make them start reading stuff. Because uninformed town can't fully help, and uninformed scum can play dumb.
I think he's softing watcher? Anyway, while I have reason to believe Tristan is town, I find it weird that he did soft; from what I remember Tristan doesn't like softing or role claiming unless its last resort. Something to mull over.
Yeah, don't think he's softing watcher. Watcher wouldn't so strongly make someone think someone is town at this point.
Like nobody has ever faked a claim before.. Vigilante is a common Mafia fakeclaim.
Uh, on zd not really. Fakeclaiming vig is basically a death sentence because there is almost always an actual vig and they would be counterclaimed. Especially since vig is easily proven.
Anyways, I'm kinda meh about Zachie's claim considering my role. But I'm not hard set on it being fake also due to the nature of my role. Without the claim he does look pretty bad though.